Ellard or Tyson?

[thetruth011]

Need to trade jack Martin, was going to trade to Tyson but then saw Ellard in th same price range.. He any good of a pickup?

[E-Lemon_ator]

I would go with Tyson mate, see him scoring higher and will play every game (pending injuries) in a developing side.
Ellard I dont think will get the same opportunities and is also a potential sub.
Easy choice for mine

[Ricochet]

I love Ellard. He's a tackling machine, hard as nails and a WA boy :)
but with Judd and Carrots still to come back into that side I would say his JS would be scratchy
go Tyson mate

[kilbluff1985]

Tyson has the best JS would go him

[Doggoneit]

I love Ellard. He's a tackling machine, hard as nails and a WA boy :)
but with Judd and Carrots still to come back into that side I would say his JS would be scratchy
go Tyson mate

I'll be having a good look at Ellard this week - I reckon Mick will love his forward pressure, but as you say not sure on his JS - will need to do a bit of research.
Plus I will only consider if he will generate more cash than cheaper rookies.

If you can afford to keep Martin on your bench for one more week it will be well worth it to get a second look at both of them.

[MLS]

If you can afford to keep Martin on your bench for one more week it will be well worth it to get a second look at both of them.

I agree with this.