Ryder, Mcevoy or Nic Nat?

[shuester]

Really stuck on which one to go with.
Have thought hard about each and have positives/negatives for all three so need some of your advice.
Thoughts?

[GoLions]

Well, I wouldn't want Ryder in my team at the end of the year because when Belly comes back his scores will most likely drop.
Big Boy could do well, but can't see him being a top 5 ruck. Would prefer to pay the extra 15-20k for one of NicNat/Leuey.
NicNat could be a top 3 ruck easily if he stays fit, but that is a very big if. Would choose him or Leuey over these other 2 guys though.

[E-Lemon_ator]

Big boy for me.  Cant rely on ryder and theres a ?? over nic nat.  Will be a bit underdone as has basically no preseason. Akthough Nic Nat is likely to score more than bot,  Big boy is the one thats up and ready. 

[bensl]

i had ryder last yer.  he is frustrating because his best is great but he doesnt deliver it often enough.  in saying that i am leaning toward him over bigboy as i think bomber might get the best out of him.

[Slammer]

Definately Nic Nat. He is a gun and providing he stays fit will score well.