made changes. please rate my team

Started by alexg1993, March 13, 2014, 03:26:22 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

alexg1993

Backs - A Walker, S Mitchell, H Taylor, M Suckling, L McDonald, W Langford ( Bench T Clurey, A Georgiou)

Mid- G Ablett, S Pendulbry, T Liberatore, D Beams, B Vince, D Thomas, J Polec, X Ellis (Bench M Crouch, M Honeychurch)

Rucks- T Hickey, A Sandilands (thrulow, king)

forwards - Dangerfield, d martin, j roughead, buddy, Higgins, impey (bench Z. merrett, d garlett

AaronKirk

Def: Walker is a POD- think he will play more forward this year and thus could be hugely overpriced- at the price I'd personally much prefer McVeigh. Harry is an excellent POD- rookies fine.

Mid: Too strong here- downgrade Vince to a Melbourne teammate in Tyson or Michie- Honeychurch and Crouch have shaky JS

Ruck: Use cash downgrading Vince to upgrade Hickey to a premo- rookies and Sandi good picks (King Loophole I'd presume)

Fwd: Strong here- Garlett definitely will not play early in the season and Merrett if selected will be sub. JKH from Melbourne for one and Rohan/McDonough for the other if you have the cash. If not- McCarthy from Geelong.

Bit to work on here IMO 7/10

E-Lemon_ator

Yea I agree with Aaron.  Having to many premos in your mids weakens other lines.  You need more mid rookies and use the $$ to bolster your def & rucks.  After all, its the mid rookies that make the $$

SydneyRox

Def - Walker not a good POD - If not McVeigh - maybe a Hanley or Simpson
Mids - This is not the worst thing to see both Vince and Daisy will score enough to keep you close but they wont generate the cash or a Tyson/Michie. You also must get Dunstan in
Ruck - Need to spend more on your R1. We are all hoping sandi holds it together, but your R1 needs to be strong. Berger or McEvoy if you cant afford to go higher.
Fwd - As said - you need to move Garlett away, but otherwise looks good (though I am not a fan of Dusty)