Is this a good team or not?

[Jezza]

Here is my current team
Defenders:
B.Goddard
C.Enright
H.Shaw
L.Hodge
J.Waite
J.Hunt
B.Waters

M.Maguire
P.Davis

Midfielders:
G.Abeltt
N.Dal Santo
B.Gibbs
M.Boyd
D.Martin
L.Jetta

M.Barlow
M.Banner

Rucks:
A.Sandilands
N.Naitunai

R.Warnock
W.Skipper

Forwards:
N.Riewoldt
B.Harvey
K.Tippett
B.Hall
P.Dangerfield
C.Mayne
T.Rockliff

C.Hitchcock
J.Podisadly

Can you please rate all the positions out of 10 and do you think my reserves are up to scratch.

[hawk_88]

Great team, apart from the defence not really one I would pick but at the same time it is difficult to find fault.

I am going to have to get picky here.

Not sure about Rockliff starting. If I had to have a cheap forward to start it would be him however I would try and make it such I didn't have to have one this year.

Hall is a risk, not one I am taking a punt on but I can see why people would.

Would start Banner not Jetta.

See... scraping the barrel here. Very good.

[Big_Cox14]

Pretty hard to fault this team. You've made a punt on Waite, but if he misses round 1 then you've at least got goose there to cover. Not sure if Davis will get a gig in round 1, even if the crows injuries. It's slim pickings in defence for the rookie prices, but Silvagni may get elevated from rookie list. So maybe consider swapping Davis for Silvagni.

Midfields fine.
Rucks - Same as mine.
Forwards - at this stage not sure about starting Rockliff. I have him on my bench, but if I was starting any cheap forward, he'd be the first. Other than that good forward line.

Overall, I rate the team an 8.5/10. Very good team and hard to fault balance wise.

[Jezza]

Thanks for the replies.