rank the rookies for scoring power

[eaglesman]

out of these rookies which one would be your last pick

DISREGARD PRICE I am interested in scoring power

tyson aish polec michie ellis dunstan crouch

[Typhnn]

michie/aish/dunstan

think aish/dunstan might struggle to get a game every week..

[hawkboy80]

aish or ellis, based on scoring only

[LF]

Aish
And he possibly has the poorer JS out of that lot as well

[eaglesman]

i have added crouch into the mix also guys

[Bully]

If in doubt I usually gravitate to the proven contested ball winners, Tyson, Michie & Dunstan would appear to be the most viable options.

Tyson should be good for 80+, he's already 3 years in the system and has some soft opponents in the rookie window. Ditto Michie, although I give the points to the former.

Careful with Aish, he's a first year player and can be very outside. His SANFL form was good without being spectacular and Brissie have a very tough early draw.

Dunstan I also like, but he's a first year player, one can't expect miracles.

Polec is the wildcard in the pack, if his preseason form is anything to go by, he's in for a stellar season. My issue with these outside types is that practice matches don't necessarily reflect reality, close checking is a rarity and the pressure will only be intensified. He's also very one-sided and it remains to be seen whether the opposition has truly exploited this weakness. For now, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt, he's in my side but will probably warm the bench in the first week. 

Ellis is in ripping form and is a must, I'm starting him on the field because he's a proven commodity. West Coast have a terrific early run so there's little to lose. I expect 80+ from him, at least up until the byes.

So if you're running with 3 rookies on the field , lock in Tyson, Michie & Ellis. The fourth is a raffle, but if in doubt I'd closely monitor the opponents and make some educated guess.

[eaglesman]

If in doubt I usually gravitate to the proven contested ball winners, Tyson, Michie & Dunstan would appear to be the most viable options.

Tyson should be good for 80+, he's already 3 years in the system and has some soft opponents in the rookie window. Ditto Michie, although I give the points to the former.

Careful with Aish, he's a first year player and can be very outside. His SANFL form was good without being spectacular and Brissie have a very tough early draw.

Dunstan I also like, but he's a first year player, one can't expect miracles.

Polec is the wildcard in the pack, if his preseason form is anything to go by, he's in for a stellar season. My issue with these outside types is that practice matches don't necessarily reflect reality, close checking is a rarity and the pressure will only be intensified. He's also very one-sided and it remains to be seen whether the opposition has truly exploited this weakness. For now, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt, he's in my side but will probably warm the bench in the first week. 

Ellis is in ripping form and is a must, I'm starting him on the field because he's a proven commodity. West Coast have a terrific early run so there's little to lose. I expect 80+ from him, at least up until the byes.

So if you're running with 3 rookies on the field , lock in Tyson, Michie & Ellis. The fourth is a raffle, but if in doubt I'd closely monitor the opponents and make some educated guess.

love your opinions there .. i have a battler between polec and michie going on ... because one of these is going to become watto as i was actually going to play 4 on field til now