rate my team please

Started by fireburner, March 12, 2010, 04:46:58 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

fireburner

I spent time on this.
Any advice would be helpful.

$2,800 left.

Backs:  C.Enright $519,000 L.Hodge $485,600 A.Mackie $421,000
            B.Houli $351,000 C.Tarrant $350,600 T.Kennelly $320,700
            L.Henderson $301,200 (J.Trengrove $100,200 A.Silvagni $83,400)

Midfield:  G.Ablett (c) $744,200 B.Gibbs (vc) $568,600 B.Prismall $465,200
               S.Hill $352,700  D.Martin $169,200
               T.Scully $179,200  (L.Jetta $114,2000 R.Bastinac $94,200)

Rucks:    A.Sandilands $538,600 H.McIntosh $485,500
              (W.Skipper $101,400 M.Lobbe $100,200)

Forwards:    P.Chapman $609,900 J.Brennan $474,800 K.Tippett $425,900
                    T.Hawkins $379,600 J.Riewoldt $372,900 T.Varcoe $370,400
                    P.Dangerfield $332,700 (J.Podsiadly $83,400 P.Davis $100,200)

dafoshow

get rid of hawkins, tarrant, hill and brennan - no subing mids??
Average team 6/10

whatahugescore

Everyones teams different mate and i love ur team in being so much different to others. might be a winner for u. But i think u have put too many average classplayers in and not enough premium, cheap buys and bargains.

Back- dont like tarrant could get malceski for a cheaper price. u haveta look at getting 3-4 premium backs. and then get some baragins like malckesi, waters, maguire, greenwood, hunt or ladson.

Mids- like it. id get rid of hill and get masten/mcveigh. And get banner or barlow for scully.

Rucks- Very strong, the only question is is it tooo strong? if u end up changing ur team u might wanna dongrade mcintosh to nic nat/seaby/tippett!

Forward Line- downgrade chappy to roo. get rid of hawkins, jack riedwoldt. try and get gia or ziebell or even if u wanna take a punt bazz hall.

Good starting point, just keep working at it and ull make an unbeliably good team.



fireburner

thanks to you both.  I made some changes...

Backs: C.Enright $519,000 L.Gilbee $453,500 A.Mackie $421,000
            B.Houli $351,000 N.Malcski $273,500 T.Kennelly $320,700
            L.Henderson $301,200 (J.Trengrove $100,200 B.Waters $151,100)

Midfield:  G.Ablett (c) $744,200 B.Gibbs (vc) $568,600 B.Prismall $465,200
               C.Masten $345,500  D.Martin $169,200
               L.Jetta $114,2000  ( R.Bastinac $94,200 M.Barlow $111,400)

Rucks:    A.Sandilands $538,600 K.Tippett $425,900
              (W.Skipper $101,400 M.Lobbe $100,200)

Forwards:    N.Riewoldt $600,500 R.O'Keefe $576,300 B.Hall $366,000
                   D.Giansiracusa $450,100 J.Ziebell $320,800 T.Varcoe $370,400
                    R.Grey $449,600 (J.Podsiadly $83,400 P.Davis $100,200)

$12,400 left