SIMPSON vs SWALLOW - D3

[Derryn23]

Already got McVeigh & Mitchell and Swallow doesn't clash with the byes. However Simpson could potentially score more than him.

Thoughts?

[BigMac93]

Simpson for me. Has averaged 90+ for the past 5 years, a much safer option than going for a potential breakout in Swallow who may not be a keeper.

[ben_020285]

Simpson. No contest.

[timtim]

For D3 - Simpson.

But Swallow is $90k cheaper and worth a look at for your D4.

[Ricochet]

Simpson is proven mate. Go with him every day of the week

[GoLions]

I was all over Swallow about a month or two ago, but since then I've come to think that even if he does improve, he still may not be a keeper and I don't want to be stuck with one of those guys that's just behind the rest, as you want to trade them but always have another higher priority and they piss you off every week. Simpson should be a top 5 back IMO, and for the record, I have him at D4

[tor01doc]

Simpleson.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)   Simpson  - - -  a keeper. Easy decision.