Please give me a rate out of 10

[Jmachete]

Any feedback will be greatly appreciated  :)


Backs: McVeigh, Mitchell, Suckling,  McDonald, Laidler, Langford (Cutler, Fuller)

Mids: Ablett, Rockliff, Cotchin, Beams, Vince, Martin, Michie, Polec (Dunstan, M.Crouch)

Rucks: Minson, Sandilands (Derickx, Thurlow)

Fwds: Dangerfield, Martin, Mitchell, Zorko, Caddy, Kennedy-Harris (Hogan, L.Taylor)


Bank: $236,600

[johnnytheboy1]

Def even though langford played real well in the nab challenge I am not sure he will get games and mcdonald should be at  b6
Mids Pretty good although it  would be even better if you get   Pendles in ahead of. Cotchin. Vince. is unique pick.
Rucks strong here
Fwds very strong with depth as far as. F5.


I give your team a 7.5/10

[love4thegame]

A bit weak in defence!  Deep mids which I'm not a huge fan on because that's were a lot of cash cows are! Beautiful rucks, pretty good front end and with that cash in hand I give you an 8/10

[Jmachete]

Yeah I am not sure whether or not to swap cotchin for pendles. Or just aim for pendles when he drops. Both pendles and ablett are very expensive.

[greco272]

Def is a disaster, Yes McDonald, Laidler, Langford all good picks, but I would expect you to only have 1 or 2 playing not three.

D.Thomas will be the same as Vince. I cant see Vince being a top 10 mid come season end. Get Thomas then burn him for a premo later in the season

Caddy good pick, fwds are really strong. No complaints.

Overall, if you are going with that backline, at least have pendals big big risk not having him this year. Collingwood are top heavy there good players score big and the low end talent score small.

[Jmachete]

Very good assessment thanks. And good theory on Collingwood.

Any tips for fixing my backline? If I include pendles I have $125,500 in the bank.

[Jmachete]

Backs: H.Shaw, Mitchell, Suckling, Webster, McDonald, Langford (Cutler, Fuller)

[greco272]

Maybe Vince down to Thomas, Martin down to Ellis.

You could leave Pendals out and see if you can upgrade preferably cutler or fuller if not Laidler for the extra cash.