This or That?

[Grufflez]

Minson or Goldstein for draft?


Goldstein, been solid and improving for a few years, wheras minson took a giant step forward last year and not sure if he can maintain it. Also more improvement in the kangas side this year than the dogs.


McVeigh or D.Martin? Not sure weather to have 4 premiums back or forward. Could go martin & r.shaw/wood or Mcveigh and any of the 200-250k rookies. Not sure these two popular guys are worth the starting price and wanna risk leaving one out.

Martin..McVeigh is overpriced by 75k

How is he overpriced? The pricing is based on his average over the course of the year. If anything he is UNDERPRICED because he scored an average of 145 over two games in the finals which don't count towards his average/subsequent price...

A defender who can pull out a score of 184 is a very rare occurrence. He had 8 scores of 120+ for the season, freak.

Yes McVeigh had a great year...106, before that though he has had 4/5 years of 93-98 averages..he will be a top 8 defender but i don't like paying over 500k for players in defence and i reckon most of these 575k blokes will come down to 475-500k ish at some stage..so i'll be starting what i think are the 475-525k keepers and picking up the other blokes mid season..IMO McVeigh is over priced atm because he won't go 106 back to back.

PS. If you're one of these guys starting Ablett,Pendles,MvVeigh,Mitchell,Danger,Martin ect ect your going to lack in other areas...i will be running with a few of these guys but simply feel we cannot over spend on the best of the best this year. just my opinion of course.cheers  :D

[Ricochet]

Minson or Goldstein for draft?


Goldstein, been solid and improving for a few years, wheras minson took a giant step forward last year and not sure if he can maintain it. Also more improvement in the kangas side this year than the dogs.


McVeigh or D.Martin? Not sure weather to have 4 premiums back or forward. Could go martin & r.shaw/wood or Mcveigh and any of the 200-250k rookies. Not sure these two popular guys are worth the starting price and wanna risk leaving one out.

Go Martin mate, He will improve further in 2014 while I can't see McVeigh improving much at all

[My Chumps]

Minson or Goldstein for draft?


Goldstein, been solid and improving for a few years, wheras minson took a giant step forward last year and not sure if he can maintain it. Also more improvement in the kangas side this year than the dogs.


McVeigh or D.Martin? Not sure weather to have 4 premiums back or forward. Could go martin & r.shaw/wood or Mcveigh and any of the 200-250k rookies. Not sure these two popular guys are worth the starting price and wanna risk leaving one out.

Yeah, I'd go Martin. More room for improvement as stated. Both are sound picks however.

Seeing as nobody else here asked a question, I'll go...

McVeigh + Cotchin or Hanley + Selwood