First Team 2014

Started by Belks, February 03, 2014, 12:33:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Belks

Def: Bartel, Mitchell, Swallow, Kolodjashnidj, Mcdonald, Fuller       Cutler, Mcstay

Mid: Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, Steven, Fyfe, Thomas, Martin, Tyson       Dunston, Taylor

Ruck: Lobbe, Grundy      Lobb, Nankervis

Fwd: Dangerfield, Wingard, Roughead, Hogan, Rohan, Garltlett         Kennedy-Harris, Impey

Byes 10/9/11
Salary Cap Rem $10,100

nperera95

Def: Too weak. Don't think it would be wise to start of with 3 rookie defenders in your best 22. No Suckling? Interesting..
Mid: Mids very strong. Clearly you've spent a lot here. Good to see that you manage to fit both Ablett and Pendles in there!
Ruck: standard ruck
Fwd: Not a bad forward. Not a fan Hogan or Rohan. Nice POD in Roughead. Haven't seen him in many teams.

Overall: Your defense is too weak. I'd suggest that you'd downgrade fyfe or Stevens to D.Beams. And you could downgrade another premium in the mid to a rookie and then upgrade your defense and get suckling and possibly another premium defender like Hanley/Hurn but that's completely up to you.

tor01doc

nperera makes a couple of good points.

If Suckling is ready to go, he is such good value.

Also if D Beams gets back, you must get on.

Not fussed about 3 def rookies - let's face it, a lot of threads last year were smashing so called elite defenders and their inconsistency.

Like Wingard but worry about Roughy minus Buddy and with McEvoy in the ruck. Will he be more stay at home this year?

Good luck.

johnnytheboy1

Def: Too weak here need to upgrade 1 of those rookies if not both
Mids: Its up to you but i think you should downgrade both Fyfe and Stevens to get in Thomas & D.Beams.
Rucks: Good ruck combnation different to some other teams.
Fwds: You will need to watch Rohan in the Nab Cup before making a decision apart from that i don't have a problem with this forward line

Iverall: I like the Bye set up here the only problem is defence i give this team a 7/10

Belks

Quote from: johnnytheboy1 on February 03, 2014, 04:07:48 PM
Def: Too weak here need to upgrade 1 of those rookies if not both
Mids: Its up to you but i think you should downgrade both Fyfe and Stevens to get in Thomas & D.Beams.
Rucks: Good ruck combnation different to some other teams.
Fwds: You will need to watch Rohan in the Nab Cup before making a decision apart from that i don't have a problem with this forward line

Iverall: I like the Bye set up here the only problem is defence i give this team a 7/10

already got thomas champ. who would you go over rough?
cheers for the feedback want to wait and see on suckling
and beams is up to 7 strikes isnt he? or did he legitimately miss 22 weeks with quad lol never getting beams again after last year selecting him with pick 1 in my draft league.....

does anyone have any other suggestions down back?

Belks

Def: Bartel, McVeigh, Mitchell, Suckling, Kolodjashnidj, Mcdonald,                 Fuller, Cutler,

Mid: Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, Steven, Fyfe, Beams, Martin, Dunston         Taylor, Hunt

Ruck: Lobbe, Grundy                                                                           Lobb, Nankervis

Fwd: Dangerfield, Wingard, Fasolo, Lennon, Garltlett, Honeychurch              Kennedy-Harris, Impey

47,800 left over.....liking this team very much potential to switch premiums to fowardline if need be but like this structure at this stage of the pre season