If you could only have one....

[Woppa15]

If you could only have one, who would it be?

Assuming all are fit and named in best 22.....

[Dayze]

All good options.
Martin 80-90
Sheed 80-85
Tyson 75-85
Michie 75-80
Aish 70-80.

Cheapest option is sheed. Martin and Tyson have best JS

[Anubis]

All of those predictions are too high. Polec is better than all those guys.

[Ricochet]

JMart by a heap. He'll be anything this kid

[Dayze]

All of those predictions are too high. Polec is better than all those guys.

U don't think Martin or Tyson can average 80 up until the byes?
U don't think Michie could average 75 or Aish 70 for 8/9 rounds?
Just my opinion bud.

[Bully]

All good options.
Martin 80-90
Sheed 80-85
Tyson 75-85
Michie 75-80
Aish 70-80.

Cheapest option is sheed. Martin and Tyson have best JS

That's pretty high for Sheed, good player but he's not a noted tackler nor is he a noted goal kicker (u/18 carnival excluded). He should chalk up 15-18 possessions a match but without the defensive pressure that may only amount to 60-70 points.

Michie/Tyson will get plenty of game time, as to who performs better is anyone's guess, personally I'll be waiting for the NAB Cup.

Aish is very outside at this stage, at the carnival only 27% of his touches were contested, a bit of a worry for SC.

Martin is the clear front runner, expensive but will almost certainly average 80 points. Lock him in if you can afford it.

[Dayze]

Sheed is the one I agree I've bumped up... But I have an enormous amount of faith in him. Time will tell. I strongly believe he could average over 80

[Speculator]

Martin and Tyson are the only 2 with almost 100% job security. Personally I think Dom Tyson will out score Martin. Just my opinion. I've heard all the Martin hype, but Tyson is entering his third year, a number 3 draft pick, a bonafide on-baller who will attend many centre bounces and who has been identified by Paul Roos as a key midfielder for melbourne this year. Has a good inside and outside game. Personally I'm sceptical how a skinny (albeit very talented) kid like martin can be better than jaegar omeara. Just my 2 cents. Now please feel free to rip me to shreds I'm expecting it. Lotta Martin love out there at the moment.

[Bluesman]

...completely agree Spec! Must only be 2 of us :)

[nrich102]

All of those predictions are too high. Polec is better than all those guys.

*posts the not sure if stupid or trolling picture for the 10th time after this guy has posted*

Polec wont average over 70. Polec is a spud.

Martin will average the best.