Please rate!! Need Help!!

[Regs81]

Backs:
Bartel, McVeigh, Mitchell, Atley, Suckling, McDonald
(Fuller, Battersby)

Mids:
Ablett, Pendlebury, Boak, D Beams, Thomas, Martin, C Beams, Dunstan
(O'Rourke, Crouch)

Rucks:
Minson, Hickey
(Nankervis, Thurlow)

Forwards:
Dangerfield, Martin, Franklin, Caddy, Taylor, Kennedy-Harris
(Garlett, Honeychurch)

$7,200 Left

[Regs81]

any feedback??

[Hmoore96]

Solid team mate, loving the unique picks
DEF: sound, loving the atley pick will hopefully breakout this year with more projected midfield minutes.
MID: solid, only concern i have is boak, he is a good POD, but you could probably get better value for money with another premium
RUC: unique but reasonable, Minson is obviously a good pick (strangely havent seen to many teams with him), Hickey is a problem IMO, he will be saints second ruck behind Longer. i reckon you should trade out Minson (as good of a pod as he is, he is to expensive for a ruckman, wait till he drops in price a bit then pick him back up and you could use that cash elsewhere) to Naitanui/Lobbe and trade Hickey to sandilands/mcintosh/longer.
FWD: solid, only potential problem may be caddy, he may have a massive year but i reckon you should use the money you gained from downgrading Minson, to upgrading him to a proven premium (eg pavlich)

all around it is a good team with just some minor potential problems but other then that good job and good luck

[juzztheball]

Backs - like the idea of loading up early! Im not starting with Bartel, can definitely see him slowing down this year, he isnt a young pup anymore. Nonetheless will be a popular pick and im sure he'll provide you with a nice season avg!

Mids - Can't really fault them. Think boak is a tad risk at 575k. Would probably rather spend the extra 25k and get someone like Watson? Nice POD though

Rucks - Dont agree with the other bloke who told you to trade Minson out, he was outstanding last year and we were all happy to pay 600k+ for Cox, why not Minson? Hickey im not sure on, there seems to be quite a few 300-400k options around which im sure you've considered, they all come with a bit of risk!!

Fwds - Solid. Seen quite a few teams with caddy, not my cup of tea but good luck!! :)