I'm done! Doing my head in now! Final draft before season kick off?

[Jack]

Here it is. I think I'm getting close now after numerous versions, tweaks. Rookies will pick themselves once the season proper starts, but having said that, I think I've got the best of them. What do you think? The only change I'm considering is perhaps Cotchin to Murphy and Yarran to Pavlich just to strengthen my forwards a tad? Is it worth it? Are there any major flaws in my team or any other ways of improving it?

DEF  J Bartel, S Mitchell, P Handley, M Suckling, K Kolodjashnij, L McDonald (T Cutler, M Fuller)
MID   G Ablett, S Pendlebury, J Watson, T Cotchin, D Beams, J Martin, V Michie, L Dunstan (J O'Rourke, M Honeychurch)
RUCK   N Naitanui, A Sandilands (F Thurlow, T Nankervis)
FWD   P Dangerfield, D Martin, L Franklin, C Yarran, G Rohan, D Garlett (J Kennedy-Harris, L Taylor)

Cash $10,100

Cheers for the help.

[skn146]

Here it is. I think I'm getting close now after numerous versions, tweaks. Rookies will pick themselves once the season proper starts, but having said that, I think I've got the best of them. What do you think? The only change I'm considering is perhaps Cotchin to Murphy and Yarran to Pavlich just to strengthen my forwards a tad? Is it worth it? Are there any major flaws in my team or any other ways of improving it?

DEF  J Bartel, S Mitchell, P Handley, M Suckling, K Kolodjashnij, L McDonald (T Cutler, M Fuller)
MID   G Ablett, S Pendlebury, J Watson, T Cotchin, D Beams, J Martin, V Michie, L Dunstan (J O'Rourke, M Honeychurch)
RUCK   N Naitanui, A Sandilands (F Thurlow, T Nankervis)
FWD   P Dangerfield, D Martin, L Franklin, C Yarran, G Rohan, D Garlett (J Kennedy-Harris, L Taylor)

Cash $10,100

Cheers for the help.

I would def swap Yarran for Pav as Pav is  a SC star and has been for years.
Would maybe even do the Cotch-Murphy swap and try and get a back up ruck because as it stands if Sandi gets injured (again) you will have no back up.
Pretty perfect team tho and believe me i have looked at a LOT!!

please rate mine below....

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,89065.0.html

[Jack]

Thanks for the feedback. Yep, Yarran is my concern so it looks like more tweaking needed. Jus thought that with Betts gone, he'll need to step up more and he's certainly got the potential ...... but does Mick like him???

Regarding your team:

Back - Love Grimes, but he's hurt me over the past couple of years so I'm a bit cautious with him. Could be a great unique though. Also, one too many rookies in defence IMO. Consider Grimes to Swallow?
Mids - Love it and can't fault it
Ruck - Had Grundy but heard that he'd tweaked hi hammy. If not, I'll probably be back on him myself because I think he's a beauty and will only get better.
Fwds - Concerns over Caddy and Bock. Great potential with Bock, but will his body stand up. Rohan's in the same boat, but from all reports he's training well and Hoarse loves him. Consider downgrading Bock to a cheaper rookie and save $80 for upgrading Caddy?

Overall, good side with some cash leftover

[skn146]

Thanks for the feedback. Yep, Yarran is my concern so it looks like more tweaking needed. Jus thought that with Betts gone, he'll need to step up more and he's certainly got the potential ...... but does Mick like him???

Regarding your team:

Back - Love Grimes, but he's hurt me over the past couple of years so I'm a bit cautious with him. Could be a great unique though. Also, one too many rookies in defence IMO. Consider Grimes to Swallow?
Mids - Love it and can't fault it
Ruck - Had Grundy but heard that he'd tweaked hi hammy. If not, I'll probably be back on him myself because I think he's a beauty and will only get better.
Fwds - Concerns over Caddy and Bock. Great potential with Bock, but will his body stand up. Rohan's in the same boat, but from all reports he's training well and Hoarse loves him. Consider downgrading Bock to a cheaper rookie and save $80 for upgrading Caddy?

Overall, good side with some cash leftover

Thanks for the feedback. Will look at GRimes v Swallow over NAB.
Grundy actually is my neighbour here in Alphington and theres no hammy issue plus I like him as a pod.