Please Rate My Supercoach Team

[Frank]

Have been playing around with this for a while and would appreciate a rating and suggestions. Thanks

B: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Fisher, Dempsey, J.Hunt, Maguire. (A.Moore, Davis)

M: Swan, Murphy, Ball, Vince, Barlow, Martin (Banner, Trengrove)

R: Clark, Seaby  (J Trengove, Warnock)

F: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Higgins,Ziebell, Dangerfield, Tippett, Rohan (DennisLane, Hitchcock)

Not sure on Maguire starting on field.  Seaby??? and dennis lane may need to go.

[billy1000]

7/10
In your backline i am not to sure on Fisher simply as he has not really done any wonders in the NAB cup so far simply because it seems Gilbert has taken over his role as that sweeping loose man in defense.
Dempsey is also another i have not been convinced of yet and i am a Essendon supporter, he shows glimpses but can go missing alot, Dempse is really one who if it pays off you'll be a hero however you could easily be a zero.
Maguire probablly should not be starting depending on how much money you have left, you should look at upgrading to a Schoenmakers or someone like that.

I like the fact you have gone with Ball however Vincehas a slight injury and is no certainty for round 1, and Murphy is coming back from a major inury aswel.

I like your rucks personally Seaby will play all 22 if uninjured however will Clark drop, stay the same or rise to become Elite... that is the unknown.

Dennis Lane has not appeared since round 1 of the NAB cup, Pavlich may still be a bit Rusty however if your not playing for the car and just the leagues that should be fine, if Higgins plays every game he will be a star, he changed the game against Port however i said "if he plays every game".

Nothing major just some things to ponder.

[Frank]

THANKS BILLY GREATLY APPRECIATED