Any advice??

[Slick5]

Def - Real strong, I like it a lot.

Mids - Not completely sold on Redden and Shuey? would prefer more proven stars like a Watson or Selwood in there with young Libba, even if you have to do some swapping around to spend some extra coin,  I feel it would be worth it. Dale Thomas could be a good cheaper option.

Rucks - Hmm Not a fan of the Canadian, will probably get more time in the middle with Mumford gone but really prefer others, Sandi is a real bargain if he stays fit and gets on the park but he has burned me a  couple of times in the past.

Forwards - Looks good, Dixon is a POD id probably go Tommy Mitchell or another forward for around that price.

[Regs81]

Made a few changes.. How's it looking??

Backs::
McVeigh, Mitchell, shaw, swallow, suckling, hunt
(Fuller, battersby)

Mids:
Ablett, pendlebury, boak, D.Beams, Thomas, Martin, Aish,  Taylor
(Dunstan, Honeychurch )

Rucks:
Dixon, Sandilands
(Lobb, nankervis )

Forwards:
Dangerfield, Martin, Franklin, chapman, bock, garlett
(Brown, Kennedy-Harris)

$3,300 left

[Baggers2012]

Def: very solid defence, Swallow looks set for a breakout year, could be a good pick. Not that unique anymore though, everyone has him!
Mids: love it, Boak will only be better this year I think. Consider some of the players with a few years in the system like Tyson, Michie, Beams & Ellis, I think some of these blokes might be more viable options than Aish & Taylor.
Rucks: not big on sandilands personally, massive risk, I would also prefer Dixon as a forward, he won't be in the top 2-3 rucks, but he may be in the top 6-8 forwards.
Forwards: if Bock is named round 1 I think a lot will take him, little bit cheaper than the Fasolo, Clark's & Higgins' as well. If he's not named Gary Rohan at 176k could be effective.
Nice side.

[Regs81]

Have played around a bit with it again!! Feedback would be much appreciated.. Thanks heaps

Backs:
McVeigh, Mitchell, Simpson, suckling, Kolodjashnij , hunt
(Fuller, battersby)

Mids:
Ablett, pendlebury, boak, S.Selwood, D.Beams, Thomas, C.Beams, michie
(Taylor, Honeychurch )

Rucks:
Sandilands , longer
(Thurlow, nankervis)

Forwards:
Dangerfield, Franklin, chapman, Pavlich, caddy, Lennon
(Garlett, Kennedy-Harris)

$9,600 left

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: The Only player i don't like here is Hunt better off with Mcdonald at B6.
Mids:First Team that i have seen Boak & Selwood in the problem with Selwood is that the eagles have depth in the Midfield Priddis gets alot of the Ball as does Shuey.The only good thing is that Kerr has retired. Selwood Kicking efficiency is down if it wasn't for that he would have a higher average than 104. Boak is a great pick always reliable.Maybe Dunstan instead of Michie.
Rucks: Weak Your No1 is injury prone and Longer is not Proven
Fwds: Far too much depth here would downgrade either Chapman or Caddy to a Rookie

Overall: The Ruck is the weakest line in this team. It has a few injury prone players (Chappy & Sandi) need improvement would look at more money to get more quality players into that team.  7/10

[eaglesman]

obviously hunt is going to become mcdonald by the start of season (it has to happen)

your midfield is a pack of guns! scott selwood is my favourite player at west coast the bloke is a frikken star and was on fire last year, he was hampered by a shoulder/arm injury and played through it - Tough and STAR! ...

u obviously wanna cheap the rucks ... i dont accept longer but i will accept grundy

I have been against pavlich all pre season and i think he has passed it (wont lose ya cash though) .. lets get chappy to martin and caddy to hogan/bock/rookie

[Regs81]

How's it looking now??

Backs:
McVeigh, Mitchell, Simpson, suckling, Kolodjashnij , cutler
(Fuller, battersby)

Mids:
Ablett, pendlebury, selwood, Watson, D.Beams, Thomas, C.beams, Taylor
(Crouch, Honeychurch )

Rucks:
Grundy, Sandilands
(Thurlow, nankervis )

Forwards:
Dangerfield, Martin, Dixon, Franklin, garlett, Kennedy-Harris
(Brown, spina)

[Regs81]

$15,600 left

[nperera95]

Def: solid defense. Don't think Cutler would get many games early but would be a handy downgrade option midseason
Mid: Very good mid. One of the best mids I've seen thus far. Like that you have both Thomas and D.Beams.
Ruck: A tad weaker than other ruck combinations I've seen. IMO, I'm not that keen on Sandilands but I do think that Grundy will keep to improve.
Fwd: Strong forward. Will be interesting to see how Buddy goes with Kippett.

Rate 8.5/10

[Regs81]

What's people's thoughts on josh hunt from GWS? Thinking of putting in him? Anyone know what he scores like

[Regs81]

Have made a few changes. How's it looking??

Backs:
Bartel, McVeigh, Mitchell, j hunt, suckling, cutler
(Battersby, fuller)

Mids:
Ablett, pendlebury, j selwood, d beams, Thomas, dunstan, crouch, Taylor
(Hunt, Honeychurch )

Rucks:
Jacobs, Sandilands
(Thurlow, nankervis)

Forward:
Dangerfield, Martin, Franklin, zorko, caddy, garlett
(Brown, Kennedy-Harris)

$29,900 left.. Would love some feedback

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: Not Sure what role Hunt will have at GWS but he is a unique pick prefer Swallow or Grimes at D4.
Mids: Solid will need to wait till after the NAB cup in regards to rookies
Rucks : Jacobs may be a good unique pick here even though he hurt alot of teams last year.
Fwds: I like the picks of Zorko & Caddy both should improve on there averages from last year. I think if you are going to have Thurlow as your R4 you may need to get someone like Dixon up forward.

Overall: Good strong team which a nice balance  give  it a 7.5/10

[Regs81]

Thanks for the feedback .. What do you suggest I do to make this team look better..