Carlton Prices and Postitions

[Master Q]

Gibbs, Bryce   Mid   $ 481 500         
   Walker, Andrew   Def   $ 470 000         
   Kreuzer, Matthew   Ruck   $ 469 200         
   McLean, Brock   Mid   $ 469 000         
   Murphy, Marc   Mid   $ 463 500         
   Simpson, Kade   Def   $ 461 900         
   Judd, Chris   Mid   $ 443 800         
   Scotland, Heath   Def   $ 443 500         
   Robinson, Mitch   Fwd/Mid   $ 411 600         
   Curnow, Ed   Mid   $ 395 400         
   Garlett, Jeff   Fwd   $ 386 200         
   Warnock, Robert   Ruck   $ 381 600         
   Lucas, Kane   Mid   $ 377 500         
   Waite, Jarrad   Fwd   $ 372 600         
   Henderson, Lachie   Def/Fwd   $ 372 500         
   Cachia, Jaryd   Mid   $ 355 800         
   Thomas, Dale   Mid   $ 346 400         
   Carrazzo, Andrew   Mid   $ 339 800         
   Yarran, Chris   Fwd   $ 329 200         
   Everitt, Andrejs   Def   $ 325 500         
   Armfield, Dennis   Fwd/Mid   $ 305 700         
   Rowe, Sam   Fwd/Ruck   $ 305 100         
   Casboult, Levi   Fwd   $ 290 000         
   Wood, Cameron   Ruck   $ 285 300         
   Tuohy, Zach   Def   $ 284 800         
   Bell, Tom   Mid   $ 277 600         
   Docherty, Sam   Def   $ 272 200         
   Jamison, Michael   Def   $ 258 700         
   White, Simon   Def   $ 238 300         
   McInnes, Andrew   Def   $ 234 500         
   Cripps, Patrick   Mid   $ 230 300         
   Menzel, Troy   Fwd   $ 227 300         
   Ellard, David   Mid   $ 224 100         
   Watson, Matthew   Def   $ 223 900         
   Graham, Nicholas   Mid   $ 185 400         
   Bootsma, Josh   Def   $ 182 800         
   Duigan, Nick   Def/Fwd   $ 162 700         
   Giles, Cameron   Def   $ 159 900         
   Temay, Tom   Mid   $ 149 700         
   Holman, Nick   Mid   $ 135 500         
   Buckley, Dylan   Mid   $ 135 500         
   Byrne, Ciaran   Def   $ 115 200         
   Johnson, Blaine   Fwd   $ 115 200         
   Reynolds, Luke   Fwd   $ 115 200         
   Sheehan, Ciaran   Mid   $ 115 200

[Ricochet]

MMurphy locked in
DThomas locked in
KSimpson considering

Thats about it for me

[henry]

No def status for Gibbs? Disappointing, he had it in fanplanner and I would've thought he'd be a fair chance of keeping it. Oh well at least we got the likes of mcveigh mitch hodge and simpson to make up for it.

MMurphy locked in
DThomas locked in
KSimpson considering

Thats about it for me

I think Murph's got some real value there, Ive got him in my fanplanner side but an issue is that he still struggles to break tags, Judd isn't getting any younger so murph gets the number one tag most weeks and his teammates struggle to help him out. It's out of Murphy and Watson for me for that m4-5 spot, Jobe is probably leading at this stage.

Daisy would have been locked for me as a forward, too risky though as a mid for me, if he gets his body right does represent value though. Im considering Kreuzer also as a bit of a unique ruck option, and simpson aswell.

[Adamant]

I reckon I'll be picking Daisy even as Mid only. He is one of the best midfielders in the comp when he is up and going, the only concern for me is that ankle. But not sure I can ignore his value.

Also looking at Simpson down back but not sure I'll be able to fit him in.

[Jroo]

Murphy, Robbo and Daisy are good value, but I won't be picking all 3.
Docherty and Menzel are cheap and I think they could both have breakout years.

[pommyadam]

Daisy as a mid only is disappointing, but can't look past him at that price point (considering the premo rooks are only 80k cheaper)

[Master Q]

Daisy as a mid only is disappointing, but can't look past him at that price point (considering the premo rooks are only 80k cheaper)

Well it depends how your midfield is structured. At the moment I have Swan, GAJ, Pendles, Jobe and Beams all in my midfield so there isn't much room for him... And I don't think I'll take many guys like Aish. He's much more expensive in FanPlanner though so that could change things.

[Adamant]

Daisy as a mid only is disappointing, but can't look past him at that price point (considering the premo rooks are only 80k cheaper)

Well it depends how your midfield is structured. At the moment I have Swan, GAJ, Pendles, Jobe and Beams all in my midfield so there isn't much room for him... And I don't think I'll take many guys like Aish. He's much more expensive in FanPlanner though so that could change things.

I have the exact same 5 mid premos as you Q, but then I've got Daisy at M6. With the inflated rookie prices there won't be as much cash generation in the middle this year, so you can afford to stack it.

[Spinking]

Blues fans - Any thoughts on specifically what role Daisy will play? Immediately into the guts, on a wing, half forward flank?

Can't see him getting much attention, but might be targeted more than he was at the pies. Really like him at that price, but just not sure what his output might be.

[Master Q]

Blues fans - Any thoughts on specifically what role Daisy will play? Immediately into the guts, on a wing, half forward flank?

Carlton have a stacked midfield. Not as stacked as the Pies but there isn't much room  :P

I think he'll be thrown straight into the guts and do some inside work, and then he'll rest in the forward line like Murphy often does.

[Jigsaw]

Murphy, Thomas and maybe Simpson for me. Couldn't believe it when I read Daisy & Gibbs were mids only, but it makes things interesting none the less.

dale thomas bases his game on gut running and he won't be fit enough to step right in to the mids so half forward will be his role and mclean will go back into the middle permanantly

Agreed. He will switch between the two roles but. I still feel he will be worth the punt early on at his price.

[Master Q]

dale thomas bases his game on gut running and he won't be fit enough to step right in to the mids so half forward will be his role and mclean will go back into the middle permanantly

Yeah but the majority of the midfield rotates or plays a secondary position. He might start at half forward but he'll definitely spend some time in the guts...