TEAR IT APART

Started by Carltonnnn, November 18, 2013, 08:37:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Carltonnnn

guys tear this apart its my first team of the year and haven't really thought about it too much but I still reckon its pretty good  :)

Kade Simpson, Heath Shaw, Trent McKenzie, Jack Grimes, Paul Seedsman, Beau Waters  (Nathan Bock, Matt Scharenberg) 

Joel Selwood, Tom Liberatore, Nathan Fyfe, Trent Cotchin, Marc Murphy, Dayne Beams, Nathan Freeman   (Jack Martin, Xavier Ellis)

Aaron Sandilands, Ben Grundy ( H-Mac, Dan Currie

Tom Rockliff, Luke Breust, Steven Motlop, Sharrod Wellingham, Dale Thomas, Viv Michie (Jesse Hogan, Thorpe) 

$14,800

GoLions

First off, I think you're missing a midfielder?

Gone too expensive down back, won't really have any cash generation. At least 1 or 2 will have to go (out of Seedsman/Bock/Waters/Grimes)
I think Pendles is a must this year, but I really like the rest of the guys you've picked
Don't like Grundy as R2, would try to turn him into a Goldy/Leuey/Minson/Mumford
Forwards are too risky I think. Would drop Breust and Wellingham for a premo and a rookie

EZA100

Definitely agree with some of the points GL has made on your team. You have definitely gone to expensive down back, would drop probably seedsman or if you want to keep him as kind of a pod then i would go with dropping grimes/waters(depending on his pre season) and go with someone cheap like maybe Suckling or a 1st round pick in Gardiner. This will give you enough cash to get a premo ruck because you have got 2 very injury prone ruckmen and a 2nd year ruckman so maybe someone like goldstein or minson.  Your midfield looks pretty good like the picks of fyfe and murphy to. With your forward line maybe look at getting a proven premium that can give you that 90+ average meaning that in my opinion drop maybe Wellingham and get Rockliff if you can afford him.