FYFE or RIOLI...who to go?

[boneman]

Def: Goddard, Hibberd, Shaw, Hanley, Gibbs, McKenzie (Clisby, Thurlow)
Mid: Ablett, Pendlebury, Barlow, Cotchin, Selwood, Kennedy, Priddis, Fyfe (Mitchell, Martin)
Ruck: Minson, Cox (McEvoy, Nicholls)
For: Franklin, Johnson, Rockliff, Martin, Kennedy, Rioli (Staker, McBean)

$16,000 2 Trades

Was looking at trading:

Clisby - Oxley (free up some $$$ and provide a DPP link with Staker)
Rioli - Walker/Nroo?

This would mean I would have to play Mitchell for Fyfe. I could move Cox fwd and play McEvoy and then have the option to trade Fyfe - whoever ???

Is there a better option?

[shorty3264]

I'd be going for the midfielder. Trade in the highest possible scorer, I think Staker has shown he is a modest scorer, also depends on your faith in Tommy Mitchell atm the moment too. But I would opt for getting a jet mid if possible.

[Rusty00]

If you're going to trade Rioli I would bring NRoo or Goldy (by switching Cox forward). I think NRoo will keep up his good form against a weakened Freo team and Goldy should score well against the Pies.

[boneman]

I'd be going for the midfielder. Trade in the highest possible scorer, I think Staker has shown he is a modest scorer, also depends on your faith in Tommy Mitchell atm the moment too. But I would opt for getting a jet mid if possible.

Who is likely to pump out the biggest score this round...Griffin against the Dee's?

[boneman]

If you're going to trade Rioli I would bring NRoo or Goldy (by switching Cox forward). I think NRoo will keep up his good form against a weakened Freo team and Goldy should score well against the Pies.

What are people's thoughts? Really torn on what to do here...

[Maritimo]

agree with Shorty, get in the best mid you can afford.

[boneman]

agree with Shorty, get in the best mid you can afford.

Griffen then? He looks the best with the highest ceiling.