The Backline Drama!

[braoudakis]

Trading H.Shaw to....

Hanley, Enright, Houli, Hibbered, Melceski, Johnson, O'brien?

The players in Bold I can trade Grimes for and keep H.Shaw.

What do i do?

[jamfrank]

Enright imo. Don't want to be worrying about whether or not the defender will go 80+ or not, like you will with most of those guys, not enright.

[ScottieD]

Personally I wouldn't trade Heath Shaw, he is in my top 6 defenders.  I'm considering trading Ibbotson to Enright this week, as I don't particularly want to rely on Mckenzie as D6.  I have the feeling Enright doesn't score well against WCE though - any opinions (or even better - stats) on this?

[jamfrank]

Personally I wouldn't trade Heath Shaw, he is in my top 6 defenders.  I'm considering trading Ibbotson to Enright this week, as I don't particularly want to rely on Mckenzie as D6.  I have the feeling Enright doesn't score well against WCE though - any opinions (or even better - stats) on this?

Last three: 78, 86, 73

[braoudakis]

Personally I wouldn't trade Heath Shaw, he is in my top 6 defenders.  I'm considering trading Ibbotson to Enright this week, as I don't particularly want to rely on Mckenzie as D6.  I have the feeling Enright doesn't score well against WCE though - any opinions (or even better - stats) on this?

Last three: 78, 86, 73

To be honest that is decent in terms of defenders this season.....

[ScottieD]

Personally I wouldn't trade Heath Shaw, he is in my top 6 defenders.  I'm considering trading Ibbotson to Enright this week, as I don't particularly want to rely on Mckenzie as D6.  I have the feeling Enright doesn't score well against WCE though - any opinions (or even better - stats) on this?

Last three: 78, 86, 73

+1.  That's not awful, you may have just made up my mind.  Geelong finishes with 2 home games too.

Also, a carrot is dangling for him to perform well - could become #1 ranked defender this week in AFL player ratings with a good game.