Which two prem defenders?

Started by dmac07, August 06, 2013, 12:48:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which two of the below?

McKenzie (& Scotland/Ellis)
10 (1000%)
Taylor (& Scotland/Ellis)
1 (100%)
Malceski (& Sctoland/Ellis)
0 (0%)
Harlett
12 (1200%)
Hibberd
5 (500%)
Dixon
14 (1400%)
Houli
2 (200%)
Scotland
5 (500%)
Ellis
3 (300%)
O'Brien
1 (100%)

Total Members Voted: 0

dmac07

So Im looking at double trading to fix up my backline this week. The rest of my team is complete with decent backup in mids/fwds.

Backs: Goddard, Heppell, Hanley, Gibbs, Ibbotson, Staker (Pittard, Thurlow).

6 trades left and 21k in the bank so funds are limited to which combination I can get. I can get any of the first three options being McKenzie, Taylor or Malceski, only if I get Ellis or Scotland as the second option.  Or I can pick any two of Harlett, Hibberd, Dixon, Houli, O'Brien, Scotland, Ellis.

Can vote up to two options if selecting from the bottom group, comments appreciated two. Playing 2nd spot and looking to get the week off with 4 trades in hand to leave me in a good position.

GCSkiwi

I'd hold Ibbo, very much a sideways trade to get rid of him. It's not like any of those defenders have been super consistent over the season.
Staker to McKenzie for me.

Colliwobblers

scotland back in great form. maybe add hibbo of all the others. but as said above not 100% consistent.

Vinny

I would go Mckenzie and Scotland.

I am bringing him in too. Not one defender this year has been completely consistent so I am taking the punt.

Good luck !

caluuum


dmac07

Leaning towards Harlett and Dixon. If I go enright/shaw I need someone cheaper than scotland/ellis for the other spot and there is no one worthwhile under the price of those guys. If Ibbotson plays however I may downgrade Hrovat>Grigg and turn Pittard>Hartlett, letting me shift Staker to the bench as cover.

dmac07

If Ibbotson is named could also go Staker > Scotland and JPK > Watson, getting rid of that wothless pile JPK who has a high score of 107 and average of about 90 over the past 6 weeks.  Thoughts?