Nic Nat & Nicholls

Started by rfc4eva, July 30, 2013, 01:54:36 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

rfc4eva

Hey guys,I have 4 trades and $110k

Backs:Goddard Heppell Hanley Hartlett Shaw Gibbs (Thurlow Staker)

Mids:Ablett Swan Pendlebury Deledio Cotchin Fyfe JPK Tom mitchell (Hrovat Dangerfield)

Rucks:Cox Nic Nat (Nicholls Currie)

Fwds:Stevie J Rockliff Roughead Franklin Kennedy A.Walker (Oxley Tunbridge)

With Nicholls in doubt should i downgrade staker so I can afford a premo ruck (goldie,kreuzer) and have enough money to upgrade lids or should I just straight swap Nic Nat 4 one of them?

Blues Blues Blues

Keep Staker, good coverage with DPP with Oxley.

Straight swap Nic Nat > Goldy (I think Kruezer is just out of reach)

GCSkiwi

NicNat has to go, sounds like he might not return whereas Nicholls is probably only a week off, will be good bench cover for you. No use having 430k tied up in NicNat if he isn't playing. Goldy or Minson are the two I'm looking at, Minson has a better draw but Goldy has posted big enough scores on the harder teams already (Has Cats, Crows, Bombers, Hawks and Pies; but has posted 105, 98, not played, 119 and 121 on those teams this year...)

Price difference is negligible, I'm trying to decide which of Minson and Goldy to get myself...