Ballantyne Vs Tippet

Started by adambruss, March 06, 2010, 11:35:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which Forward Rockliff and Hitchcock on bench

Ballantyne
3 (33.3%)
Tippet
6 (66.7%)

Total Members Voted: 1

adambruss

Ok have a doubt of who to pick Ballantyne or Tippet, have cash for either is the last spot left.  Have Clarke and Sandilands in ruck and lobe is a reserve so Tippet could be moved if injury. 


Plastic Boy

if your plan is to have a back up ruckman in Tippett in the FWD line, then you've already made your decisions to go with him over Ballantyne.  Otherwise dont have Lobbe cause he wont get games anyway.


adambruss

That is a good point if Tippet is selected then i would stick with lobbe if not then i may select roughead.  Warnock is other ruck option. 

Plastic Boy

I'd be going for Ballantyne and Roughead or Skipper as your 4th ruck.

But having said that Tippett should do well this year. And the thought of having a quality back up ruckman is very handy and a big relief going into each round.

Warnock will play as many games as his body will hold up, but he wont score high, so it might be worth having Tippett should your main rucks fall apart.