RID: Vlastuin VS Goodes

[lowry]

Quick Poll, comments would also be appreciated  :)

[kilbluff1985]

Coin flip mate just pick one

[Jroo]

Both may not play this week so wait until the teams are announced and whoever is named I'd keep.

[_wato]

If Goodes and Vlas both play this week keep Goodes, is a mature age recruit with a seasoned body, and less likely to hit that unfortunate 'wall' as Vlastuin will. Will both average similar numbers, and WB aren't the best team so there's no pressure for a spot, whereas with Vlastuin there is. Close but keep Goodes, get rid of Vlas.

[smashbox]

Goodes i think

if you take a close look at Vlaustin scores when he scored big it was mainly against poor opposition. Im not saying he only scores well against them, but it appears based on the games hes played. Goodes is more of a safe bet, plus hes a seasoned player

[Vinny]

Goodes. Mature player and more likely to carry out the season fully fit. Vlastuin being young could tire plus his very high BE is hard to ignore unless his bench cover.

[Big Mac]

Yeh i'd have to go Goodes. Vlastuin has a higher ceiling but there's more risk with him.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)
Keeping both so as to have an interchangeable emer between def and mid. But doing as you ask and just choosing one,  Goodes hands down. Vlast has the skill and potential but Goodes has the mature body, better JS and a desperation born of a very limited lifespan as a player. ;)

[justaverage]

Goodes may miss this week with a wrist injury

[outandover]

From Supercoach Paige off of Facebook.

News coming through that Nick Vlaustin could be sidelined this week with an injury concern, after spending the final 16 minutes of the game against the Bulldogs on the pine.

These guys are hit and miss with their info but i wouldnt be suprised if they do give him a spell.

[Frozensage]

if they both miss then i'm not gonna do any trades this week... got too many to cover in the back!!

[Mat0369]

From Supercoach Paige off of Facebook.

News coming through that Nick Vlaustin could be sidelined this week with an injury concern, after spending the final 16 minutes of the game against the Bulldogs on the pine.

These guys are hit and miss with their info but i wouldnt be suprised if they do give him a spell.

He was iced up and came back on when Chaplin got injured. I don't think it was anything serious otherwise he would not have come back on

[outandover]

Yeah thats true but theres no saying that hes not pretty sore. I have him, so I hope he does get up but I wouldnt be suprised if he doesnt.