Rate my team and be critical!!!

[bboys]

Please rate my supercoach team.. Only my second year at it, but appreciate ANY feedback/abuse/criticism/pointers/tips/ridicule etc

Backs
Goddard, Doughty, Gilbee, L.Brown, Dempsey, Ladson, Waters (M. Maquire, P.Davis)

Mids
Swan, Chapman, Goodes, Rich, Rosa, C. Young (J. Trengove, L.Jetta)

Rucks
Ryder, Mumford (Naitanui, Charman)

Forwards
Higgins, Schnieder, Roughead, Hall, Ziebell, Rockliffe, Gumbleton (J.Neagle, B.Reid)

FIRE AWAY!!!!!!

[ossie85]

Leigh Brown, as much as I love the big fella, is a big no I'd think. Waters, Ladson, Maguire risks, but I'll be taking similar ones.

Chappy is old, and should be played in the forward line if at all. Goodes also should be in forward line. Rosa/Young are interesting choices. Your midfield is probably too strong though, you may have to play a rookie or two.

Charman is gone IMO.

Forward line a bit weak, not a fan of Roughie after he burnt me last year.

[Solat]

L Brown is a spud

Chapman & Goodes to fwds and use schneider/roughy money on mids

mumford is not a scorer, look elsewhere

unique team, might be a roughy for a weekly prize but probably not a season contender

[jeffery]

not a good team at all

[bboys]

hahaha love the feedback, especially the last one..

Anyway i just went nuts and made 8 changes

Backs
Brown Ladson and Waters Out
Shoenmaers, Malceski and C. COrnes IN

Mids
Goodes (Too Pricey) OUT
Chappy to Forward Line
Haselby and Boak IN

Rucks
Charman and Mumford OUT
McEvoy and Lobbe IN

Forwards
Roughead and Schneider OUT
Chapman and Tippett IN


FIRE AWAY AGAIN!!!! I DARE YOU ALL!!!! (But seriously i really appreciate the help)

[Blueboys]

bboys jeffery  is right thats a shower team, you should just re-start! If you can't work out a team look at the once that have been posted with good comments and start there!  ;D

[bboys]

haha.. are you offended there are no carlton players? :P

[Blueboys]

I only have gibbs in my team and may get Judd later, it's not about which team it's about the player, run that team and you will fail for sure!   ::)

[alman]

Malceski is having a great preseason but may struggle to get the ball as often when shaw is playing.. Cornes is capable of a big score but was pretty inconsistent last season - maybe see how waite plays on the weekend