Rate my team out of 10

[TheSmokey]

Drummond, Hodge, Gilbee, Waite, Dempsey, Ladson, Maguire, (P Davis, A Silvagni)

Mitchell, Gibbs, Watson, Cooney, S Thompson, Trengove, (Morabito, Banner)

M Clark, Hille, (Jordan Roughead, Fitzpatrick)

J Brown, Harvey, Franklin, Hahn, S Johnson, Buchanan, Gumbleton, (Rohan, Rockliff

Not sure how many games Gumbleton will play, and there's at least one first year player starting down back, mid and up forward. Thoughts?

[salce]

8/10 id say. Don't know about Hille, had good form against melbourne in the NAB Challenge, maybe nic natinui. Johnson is another risk, Clark has a contest with the ruck with Charman and Leunberger returning, but overall a decent team

[DALGER]

5 is the highest ill give any team without Ablett