Andrew Walker????

[Jmachete]

137, 70, 137

In the first 3 rounds playing new role running out of defence.

Is he worth getting in for Zorko?

[shorty3264]

If he keeps that running half-back role, yes! Yarran is playing up forward, while Walker is the play maker out of defence. Really depends on his security in that role.

[Jmachete]

This is true, because he went forward in the pies game which is the one where he scored low, I assume if he is getting more ball back there he would stay there though?

[ubeaut]

Very tempting and is playing as well as any time in career. But too risky for me. Better last week if at all any way. As u say it's dependent on his role. he is a bloody good forward and who else is there when waite is nijured?

[ronl]

He's a bit prone to getting injured when you can least afford it, I can see the reasoning is solid, but I'd still be wary.

[Jroo]

I'm not sure he can keep it up or if he does teams will tag him and I don't reckon he'll handle the attention well. I probably wouldn't pick him  :-\

[Baggers2012]

Im a passionate Carlton fan, I have been going to 15+ Carlton games a year since Walker was drafted & im not certain whether he'll spend more time foward or back this year, he'll probably be a swing man all season. Personally i think he should play largely as a foward that has spells in the midfield. Proven to be a good impact player in the mids. He kicked 56 (if i remember right) goals in 2011 so he's a quality foward. Also if Walker is playing as a Fwd/Mid it allows Yarran to play off half back, when Yarran's at his absolute best he reminds of Andrew McLeod, and i loved Andrew McLeod!

For supercoach though, i'd give him a miss. Not enough clarification on his role in the side.

[Jmachete]

some very interesting insights, cheers to all :)

[johnnytheboy1]

I am seriously considering bringing him in for Zorko otherwise will go with Martin or Westhoff.