The Weakest Link - Stevenson, Pittard and Heath

Started by ttste1, April 16, 2013, 11:55:09 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which one would you trade to Terlich?

Lewis Stevenson ($160,200)
1 (3.3%)
Jasper Pittard ($171,000)
17 (56.7%)
Campbell Heath ($158,500)
3 (10%)
Don't trade
9 (30%)

Total Members Voted: 2

ttste1

What are your thoughts?

Probably all equal on JS but Terlich seems like he will have a greater ceiling giving his kicking ability...

Ricochet

All three have -BEs and with GC this week I would consider keeping all three. But if you do have a left over trade i would go with Pittard because his 28 from the weekend will stay with him for the next two weeks, compared to Stevenson's 40 and Heath's 49

fertalong

I would say Pittard based on the first 3 rounds. Also his 28 will be in price calculations for another 2 weeks so his price rises won't be a big.
Before the season I would have said Heath, but he's actually been quite conistent.

ttste1

I like where both your heads are at...

In light of that, I should probably cut K.Mitchell to Crouch or other and Zorko to Buddy or Stevie J.

What are you guys doing?

Ricochet

Yep Mitchell definitely has to go.
Is Zorko your only other problem?
I have him as well and I'm going to keep him. He has already dropped too much cash and if he only gets 75odd on the wkend he will only drop 20k-ish. I'm hoping he bounces back and gets back to a 480k+ price range.

Toga

Mitchell has to go mate, he's on the rookie list again so 100% won't be playing this week! :(

And tbh I would keep all three of those guys - still a lot of cash to be made, and although Terlich has looked good so far there's every chance he could have one or two off-games over the next couple of weeks putting you in the same situation... Stick by Pittard, Heath and Stevo, they're still not fat enough to cull yet ;)

I personally am trading Kommer and Zorko this week if that helps..

Memphistopheles

Pittard is the one to cut. As he started at a higher price he'll make cash slower if they all score similar (which they have been doing).

Terlich has more cash to make than him and should average a bit higher

Plus you bank the most cash from the Pittard to Terlich deal than any of the others.

No brainer really. The only consideration is that Port play GC this week so all three should score reasonably well and that will help them make more cash.

So if you have more pressing issues sort them out first (we should get a look at Wright next week for a def DG option and Docherty was also the Lions' reserves best on the weekend) but if not do this one.

Spanner221

What about Jack Hutchins? He's looking like he's going to get a huge price rise as well.

S_Coach99

#8
Remember Pittard was tagged on the weekend. A strategy from a losing Adelaide, I'm not too sure many coaches will be running to adapt that strategy?

He did score better in the 2 previous weeks.

HOLD all three I say. but if you must Pittard.

Ramus

Wait for the teams to be announced, one of them may get dropped and help make the decision for you!

If they are all picked to play I woul hold fire and wait for them to fatten up a bit, even though the extra number of trades have cheapened their worth, a trade still has to be of good value!