Jayman's Round 3 Trade Options...

[Jay]

Unfortunately I do not have enough cash for Karny --> JJK (1.2k off >:()

So if I want to trade Karny I'll likely have to get the cash elsewhere as I can not see any great options for a straight swap, Pettard maybe? I could downgrade him to Sam Rowe...

OR

Bite the bullet and trade Zorko or even Walker but I have faith in both of them. Will both drop cash though so may be alright short term to allow me to get JJK

OR

Could move Cox fwds and try and get Leuey in... Need to work out $2,000 elsewhere though :-\ Macaffer --> Rowe?

Other options are just getting on the Heath bandwagon for some cash, would mean trading Terlich. Or just hold my 30 trades

[Mat0369]

Wait for the teams tomorrow. Macaffer could get dropped as he is on an extended bench. If he is then Macaffer to Rowe could be an option

[Jay]

Sort of hoping Macaffer gets dropped to make my decision easier - what are the odds?

Macaffer --> Rowe & Karnezis --> JJK/Leuey is my ideal scenario... Will decide which one when I get there ;)

[Torpedo10]

Hey Jay,

I honestly think Zorko>Bartel & Karny>JJK will give you the best value. Bartel is a quality scorer.

[Jay]

Im guessing you guys reckon it would be better to trade Tex not Zorko?

Seems a bit of a waste to trade Macaffer if named

[Locinator]

I reckon if you have Walker he has to go. He might pull out a couple huge ones in the coming weeks against Melbourne and Gold Coast but he can't cope with the extra attention. If you had to go one between Bartel and Rioli I would go Rioli because even if he isn't playing midfield he gets so many tackles to make up for the lost possessions. Bartel is uncertain to me because his getting all his points in the 4th quarter and he may be reliant on close games to get good scores against weaker teams. I'm not saying his a dud pick cos he is a champ but I would personally go for Rioli as a unique.

I have gone with Lee over Rowe because I don't have DPP in the rucks so I don't need it. If you think you really need it go for him but if not Tom Lee should score more than Rowe and should have better JS with only Maister challenging his spot.

You have to get rid of Karny I would definitely look at JJK, As a alternative if you want to go unique I think Ricky Pettard could get consistent 70-80s and will probably be more consistent than JJK but most likely wont score quite as high.

Leuy is an interesting one, I would personally prefer him over JJK. He did play Sam Jacobs which is encouraging on his performance but I hold and see how he goes this week against Zac Smith or Charlie Dixon who are better around the ground to get a real indication.

[Mat0369]

Caff dropped. Problem solved

[Jay]

Almost set on going Karnezis & Macaffer --> Leuenberger & Rowe. Would involve moving Cox fwd which unfortunately leaves me with Rowe and Cox in the fwds but I can't see any better options.

In terms of prices I could wait a week BUT I'm going for overall so wouldn't mind chasing the points.

So yeah should I play it safe and wait a week or chase the points and get the Berger in?

[Jay]

Have updated the poll :)