Still undecided

[Slammer]

Still cannot decide which way to go.

1. Newman to L. Brown and Karnesis to Buddy

or

2. Newman to Hanley

B: Godd, Gibbs, Duffield, NEWMAN, Goodes, Pittard (Stevenson, Terlich)
M: Ablett, Pendles, Swan, JPK, Fyfe, Omeara, Viney, Wines (Hill, MItchell)
R: Kreuzer, Leuy (Blicavs, Rowe)
F:Cox, Bartel, Rocky, J.Kennedy, KARNESIS, MCaffer (Dwyer, Neade)

30 trades, $82K

Leaning towards option 1

[AFEV]

As much as I disagree with downgrading Newman... Karnezis, Macaffer, Dwyer and Neade needing to make up your F5/6 every week has me very nervous.
So I'd go with option number 1.

May be worth adding a poll also.

[Slammer]

Thanks Sid.

This one is killing me. I simply cannot make up my mind.

[the captain]

First one by far. Karnezis isn't even in the Brisbane team, so there is no point holding onto him. Buddy is better than Hanley and Brown is better than Karnezis.

[23rookie23]

I disagree I think option 2 is the best by far.

Its difficult without seeing the rest of your team but 1 thing remains true!

The first price rise of a rookie is the best and if you miss out on that you wont be able to get it back.

Newman to Brown/Heath carries the least risk and sets you up with $$ for upgrades.

As for Karney to Buddy you do not need to make this trade this week as Karney is likley out so you wone lose money on him and Buddy is set to go down in value.

Better to go to Neade/Dwyer/JJK if you dont have them IMO.