Big trades

Started by Footy God, April 08, 2013, 10:37:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which trade

Karnezis-Patton, JPK-Watson
7 (26.9%)
JPK-Moloney, Karnezis-Kennedy
19 (73.1%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Footy God

Gibbs, Heppell, Goddard, Goodes, Stevenson, Terlich (Pittard, Heath)
Swan (C), GAJ, Murphy, Pendles, J Kennedy, Wines, Omeara, Viney (Jones, Kommer)
Cox, Goldy (Blicav, currie)
Rockliff, Bartel ,Martin, Franklin, Karnezis, Dwyer (Neade, Caff)


Option 1:Karnezis-Patton, JPK-Watson
Will have to play 2 of 4 rookie priced players on the field. Is Watson the right choice?

Option 2: JPK-Moloney, Karnezis-Kennedy
Will leave a lot of cash, but end up with 2 mid pricers

antonc

Prob would go option 1.
You will get a top 8 mid in watson and a decent cow in Patton.
Moloney and kennedy might outscore them in the next few weeks though!

westy501

if you do kennedy to watson how much cash will you have?

Footy God

Quote from: westy501 on April 08, 2013, 10:57:00 PM
if you do kennedy to watson how much cash will you have?
nothingg

However if I do the 2nd option I will have 181k

westy501

Option 3: karny to rowe.. allows for DPP with cox... Then if you really want watson you can trade JPK...

Ricochet

Quote from: westy501 on April 09, 2013, 09:00:39 AM
Option 3: karny to rowe.. allows for DPP with cox... Then if you really want watson you can trade JPK...
But then he has two rookies starting in the fwd line?

I would go with option two personally mate. So much cash and Moloney has GC this week so he should score within 10-15 points of Watson, but JJK will kick a bag against MElbourne and should smash Patton's score.

powersuperkents

Trade two is a value trade. A lot of cash to be made

Diehardfan

I think trade 2 is the way to go will free up a lot of extra cash. Trade 1 would mean that all five of your top midfielders would be out in Round 13 requiring some sideways trading.