How does this beams trade sound

[coyley]

Hi all I'm thinking this option for a beams trade to GIBBS is this crazy

[fertalong]

You should have gibbs in your backline.
It's not the worst trade in the world, but for your mids, there are better and more reliable options than gibbs.
Watson, Pendles, Cotchin, Swallow etc etc

[Windigo]

You don't have Gibbs at all?  :o

I'd get him in, but not in the mids. Beams>Jobe.

[Holz]

pretty simple do whatever possible to get gibbs into your backline. If he was a mid only he would still be a good pick up.

[dillez]

Its simple... GET GIBBS!

[coyley]

Hi thanks for the help so farther team currently looks like this I've been trying to figure out how to get Gibbs in this week and it looks like the beams is the only way. I could downgrade beams and upgrade yarren to Gibbs but not sure as yet as I could use the trades else were my teams looking like aess after round one
Backs/ p Henley. H harlett. D heppell. B Goddard. C yarran.  L Stephenson.
Bench j pittard. D terlich

Midfeild/ g ablett. D swan. P dangerfeild. O wines. B goodes. J omeara. L Whitfield. K Mitchell
Bench beams. D rampe

Rucks/ p Ryder.  Blivces
Bench.  Daw. Currie

Forwards/. Franklin. Rockliff  zorko. Cox. Karnezis. Macaffer
Bench neade. Dwyer

[fertalong]

Your backline is solid as is so I wouldn't recommend a sideways trade. Upgrade to Gibbs at a later stage.

Personally what i would do is downgrade Beams to Viney then trade Yarran for Watson/Pendles by moving goodes into DEF.