WHICH TRADES TO MAKE?

[dtfreak]

Hey guys, please vote and comment to tell me which trades I should do this week...

CASH LEFT: $10,000

OPTION 1
Brett Deledio > Michael Barlow
Zac Smith > Matthew Leunberger

OPTION 2
Brett Deledio > David Mundy
Zac Smith > Matthew Kreuzer

OPTION 3
Brett Deledio > Michael Barlow or David Mundy
Lachie Whitfield > Jack Viney

OPTION 4
Lachie Whitfield > Jack Viney
Zac Smith > Matthew Leunberger

OPTION 5
Just one of the 3 trades I've mentioned above (tell me which one)

[Jroo]

I'd go option 4 if Berger is named.
Viney is better than Whitfiled and Berger better than Smith so you can't lose.
I would keep Deledio, he was close to best on ground for 3 quarters last week.

[GoLions]

I'd go option 4 if Berger is named.
Viney is better than Whitfiled and Berger better than Smith so you can't lose.
I would keep Deledio, he was close to best on ground for 3 quarters last week.

+1. Although maybe wait a week on getting Berger just to see how he goes. Definitely Whitfield-->Viney though.

[fertalong]

Option 4 for me also.
I'm going to bring in berger for smith this week if named. I can't see him getting a sub50 score, and at the very least, berger won't drop in price.

[dtfreak]

I'd go option 4 if Berger is named.
Viney is better than Whitfiled and Berger better than Smith so you can't lose.
I would keep Deledio, he was close to best on ground for 3 quarters last week.

+1. Although maybe wait a week on getting Berger just to see how he goes. Definitely Whitfield-->Viney though.

Thanks guys, yeah Whitfield and Viney will probably both average in the low 70s, however I like Viney's job security and I see him playing 20+ games this season, whereas Whitfield looks likely to play 15+ and it will be tough to fit in to the GWS midfield all the time with the likes of Coniglio, Shiel, Scully, Ward, Greene, Treloar, Tyson rotating through there. Not sure if I should see how Leunberger goes against the Crows and Sam Jacobs and then pick him up, or to get him straight away because it will be tough for Zac Smith who is playing Sydney at the SCG with Shane Mumford and Mike Pyke.

[Ziplock]

whitfield isn't really competing with most of those blokes though- imo, his main competition for spots are with players like hoskin-elliot, palmer etc.

[yorgis]

trade out lids? what happens if he rips it up against the saints and mundy/barlow  dont excel against the bullies ??

whitfield to viney yes smith to luey yes but onlt if both picked

[Jigsaw]

Definitely Option 4, but I'd wait on the Berger unless you can't afford to upgrade Smith to someone else (Kreuzer, Goldy, Mummy come to mind) and you really want to ditch Smith. I ended up going Smith -> Goldy, though haven't decided 100% if I'm going to roll with that just yet.

Wouldn't trade out Lids just yet. I've got Lids myself and will continue to back him in for awhile.

[Sapientia]

I'd go option 4 if Berger is named.
Viney is better than Whitfiled and Berger better than Smith so you can't lose.
I would keep Deledio, he was close to best on ground for 3 quarters last week.

If you feel the compulsion to trade, the above hits it on the head.

Why waste a trade with Lids though, lock and load man.