my latest team, give me your thoughts and rating, thanks

[TheBombres]

B:    Goddard - drummond - hodge - gilbee - malceski - ellis - hunt
      (maguire - silvagni)

M:  selwood - mitchell - watson - cooney - cotchin - trengrove
      (martin - jetta)

R:   tippett - charman
      (lobbe - roughhead)

F:   riewoldt - o'keefe - franklin - johnson - dangerfield - ballantyne - 
      gumbleton
      (rockliff - hitchcock)

a few weak spots i guess but with the prices the way they are you've gotta punt on a few rookies and blokes like gumbleton (if he gets through pre-season) i reckon so any thoughts/ratings

[TheBombres]

anyone got ANY feedback????????????????

[whatahugescore]

Good team mate. Nice backline, I'd personally try and get kennelly but you have malceski instead of him which is fine as well. Maguire as a sub is not worth it i reckon u shuld look at getting a rookie, who can be a cash cow... J.Lisle, Trengrove for port, Phil Davis frm ade. Midfields are good-but id get mastern over cotchin. Rucks are average but you have to have lower scoring section of ur team so guess uve decided thats ur ruck dptment. Fwds are pretty good if gumbles gets going. 7.5/10

[TheBombres]

Gee thanks for the positive feedback mate. I did decide to go cheap with my rucks to have more money elsewhere but will take on board your comments especially about maguire, cheers

[Crushemall]

Very Good I can't find too many holes I agree with fringe players and injury proners that have had a good off season like Malcheski I think he's way better value than the Irishman who apparently never scored that well b4 anyway.

I think a must haves based on reliability and value Hodge, Maguire is a very fullback option to replace Merritt at some stage, cooney hopefully will be back to his best and is the best value brownlow bet, jetta will play a role at the swannies and looks a real great prospect i question his scoring ability as a midfielder though  he will be a cash cow, Charman could very well be the #1 ruck at lions as voss may push clark forward to be a third target to really put pressure on defensive teams with b1 & b2, Dangerfield is a must on his upside especially now knights and otten are injured early, I would like to see Gumby on the bench as he could pull a fingernail early on although as a risk could be a cash cow if he hardens up

I think there is a few overpriced midfielders and mitchell is definitely one as he will be playing a lot more forward this year, you must find money for big sandi or cox they are musters. Franklin if u can cover him for round 1 yet i dont think you'll be able to.

Hope my proxy wisdom has helped in some way, 8/10

Please have a look at mine and see what you think

[TheBombres]

BACKS
                  Goddard      Drummond      Hodge     Gilbee
                   
                                 Ellis      Malceski        Hunt

( Davis   Silvagni )

MIDS
                            Selwood      Mitchell       Watson

                                 Cooney     Zieball     Martin
( Trengrove   jetta )

RUCKS

                                       Tippett        Charman
(Roughhead    Lobbe)

FORWARDS
                      Riewoldt     O'Keefe     Johnson     Franklin

                            Dangerfield   Ballantyne   Gumbleton
( rockcliff  Podsiadly)

Made some changes anyone think they've improved it or weakened it???
Got 40 grand left so possiblity of an upgrade, any help welcome