Viney or Whitfield?

[its me lads]

I swear i have seen this before but i looked through 15 pages and couldn't find it. If it exists feel free to link me it. Otherwise, What do you think?

[Jukes]

Neither

Whitfield is too expensive, Viney is too rubbish.

[Colliwobblers]

i disagree, viney for me if named round 1.

whitfield is too expensive.

Viney is a future star of the competition, Jukes says a lot of outrageous things, and surprisingly most are more true than false,

but this statement is false and farcical and outrageously spuddish, viney is not rubish he will dominate. Already played VFL as an undergae player and was the best of any underage player in the VFL.

dominated in the u18 last season averageing 25+ disposals ranking elite for a midfielder.

oh yeah he is rubbish - steer clear of viney.

[Ricochet]

Yep Viney for me, but JS could be an issue. Melbourne have said they will "ease" him into AFL footy