Pendles vs Cotch vs Deledio

[KoopKicka]

Can only roll with one of these guys, currently have Lids for a POD and bar Freo, isnt tagged.



Current Mids: Ablett, Swan, ?????, JPK, Fyfe, Wines, Mitchell, O'Meara (Kent, Kommer)

[Windigo]

Gotta have Pendles.  8)

[Colliwobblers]

Gotta have Pendles.  8)

+1 after danger and shuey how can you go past the tried and tested.

although Lids and Cotchin still solid option neither is a proven elite mid yet, but I think while cotchin will be better lids may score better if cotchin cops the #1 tag - f course that could go in reverse also :)

suffice to say pendles - and bank the points week in week out.

[tbagrocks]

Cotchin sucks! Will score less than 63 point!

You heard it first ;)

[ADEZ]

Personally, I have all three, can see upside in all of them...
If you were only going for one it would have to Pendlebury my a mile

[Toga]

I've got Pendles and Cotchin out of those three at the moment - but being a tigers boy I'm trying real hard to slip Lids in there as well.

Outta the three I just think Pendles is an absolute must-have this season... Averaged inside the top 10 mids last season on a broken leg for half the year, imagine what he could do this year! :o

Cotchin and Deledio will once again be close imo... As you've pointed out Deledio will get tagged against Fremantle who he struggles against the Crowley tag but if teams continue to try to tag Cotchin, he will run amok outside and tear it to pieces. Both to average 110+ this season again imo...

Probably can't go wrong with any of them but I'd be choosing Pendleberry

[millencholy]

I have Pendles and beleive he will be one of the top scorers in the comp this year, so you should put him in first. I am on the fence with Deledio and Cotchin - If Cotchin starts getting more attention from opposition taggers I think Deledio becomes a real POD and the better choice, should avg 115+

[Adamant]

While I rate Lids and Cotchin as good picks... this shouldn't be a question. Pendles is a 100% must have for 2013.

Pendles - 118
Lids - 111
Cotch - 108-111

[Jukes]

Pendles easily, will be the second highest average unless Boyd/Beams/Cotch/Lids massively step it up.

My predictions:
Cotch: 111
Lids: 113
Pendles: 119

[Ricochet]

Pendles will average at least 5 points more than Lids and Cotch