Stanley or Grimes

[powersuperkents]

Grimes is more proven and also more injury prone. Stanley is more consistent but lower ceiling...

Current backline:
Goddard, Stanley/Grimes, Gibbs, Heppell, Goodes, Stevenson, Terlich, Docherty

[Adamant]

Stanley, Stanley, Stanley.

Unique, super consistent, absolute lock in the top 5 defenders.

[Ricochet]

Normally I would say Stanley butI think he only played one NAB Cup game. He should score similar, if not more, than Grimes but based on his preseason I would pick Grimes.

[Toga]

Normally I would say Stanley butI think he only played one NAB Cup game. He should score similar, if not more, than Grimes but based on his preseason I would pick Grimes.

Gotta agree with Ric here - Stanley is a gun that's for sure and should definitely be int eh top 6 backs come year's end, but on;y had the one NAB game and was a bit underwhelming in it...

Grimes is more injury prone but I expect him to flourish at Melbourne in their rebuilding stage! :)