Team to beat? need your opinion!

Started by Big Poppa, February 26, 2010, 06:49:30 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Big Poppa

ok well think i have my team pretty sorted depending on rest of nab cup and who gets named round 1. so let me know what u think and how i can improve
Backs:duffield, h.shaw,hodge,carazzo,kennelly,c.pearce,waters (markovic, silvagni)

Mids:selwood, o'keefe, harvey, ball, burgoyne,martin (jetta,barlow)

Rucks: Sandi, hille (charman, trengrove)

Forewards: riew, pav, higgins, franklin, medhurst, williams, rohan (rockliff, gumbleton)

im not too sure on williams or to go with ziebiell. And clancee pearce looked really good other night so will monitor closely but hoping for big things..  pls give some feedback

verda32

no sure bout a few a your players but i think they all could pay off like, ball, burgoyne, medhurst, rohan, waters, pearce and hille but good luck to u.

bjrouse


Big Poppa


tails277

no ablett = 4/10.... allot of players making comebacks from injuries... 3/10 i reckon..

jameswilson


Big Poppa

there are only 2 ppl that havnt played this year being hille (who is polaying this week) and burg who is expected next week, and both are bit of risk but will definatly go up if they stay fit!
so can someone with a clue(not tails) give some feedback pls  ;D

tails277

big poppa, fairly sure waters was injured all last year aswell as charman also i think you may find gumby didnt play a game last year aswell... kennelly i would take a chance on, but he also didnt play a game...

and as you mentioned hille and burgoyne....  so i count 6 players.....

big risks...... 3/10

Big Poppa

true about waters but am waiting to see if he plays pre season, and just ment on field, everyones bench changes when teams are named so not really looking at that yet

Jenko

get hille midway through the year not going to go anywhere at the start

Trace


Crushemall

I guess to have your big names you need cheapies that if fit and playing above average will have a lot of upside. Players in this catergory include Waters, Hille, Charman (I have him in my run on, I like). then theres Gary Rohan big wait and see if he gets a start at all this year. Burgoyne, Medhurst, Williams big liabilities
This team needs work 5.5/10

tails277

the tribe has spoken  bp.......

so can someone with a clue(not tails) give some feedback pls

plenty of feed back there buddy