Advice needed quickly!!!!!

[Scrays]

ok so here is the team. Let me know what you think.

Def: Goddard, Shaw, Enright, Goodes B, Pittard J, Docherty S EMR: Terlich, Clurey
Mid: Pendlebury, Selwood J, Cotchin, Boyd, Murphy, Thompson S, Wines O, O'Meara J EMR: Jones M, Viney J
Rck: Cox, Mumford EMR: Rowe S, McBean L
Fwd: Roughead, Walker T, Brown J, Varcoe T, Macaffer B, Neade J EMR: Lee T, Membrey T

I've got $40,600 to play with.
Any advice apprecaited!

[Scrays]

quick change...few looks but no comments...don't be shy

Def: Goddard, Shaw, Reilly B, Goodes B, Pittard J, Docherty S EMR: Terlich, Clurey
Mid: Pendlebury, Selwood J, Cotchin, Boyd, Murphy, Pearce C, Wines O, O'Meara J EMR: Jones M, Viney J
Rck: Cox, Mumford EMR: Rowe S, McBean L
Fwd: Roughead, Walker T, Brown J, Varcoe T, Macaffer B, Neade J EMR: Karnezis, Membrey T

I've got $6,100 to play with.
Any advice apprecaited!

[Griffo1982]

Reilly to gibbs & who is clurey? swap him & docherty to stevenson & luke brown.
ditch pearce for lukas/moloney/whitfield/mitchell.
Who are McBean & Membrey? swap them for currie & lee.
Brown is past it, swap with bartel or rockliff.

[Scrays]

yeah a few of them were always going to come out of the side.
Will take a punt on Lucas but happier now with the structure

Def: Goddard, Shaw, Gibbs, Goodes B, Pittard J, Docherty S EMR: Brown L, Stevenson L
Mid: Pendlebury, Selwood J, Cotchin, Boyd, Rich D, Lucas K, Wines O, O'Meara J EMR: Jones M, Viney J
Rck: Cox, Mumford EMR: Rowe S, Currie
Fwd: Roughead, Walker T, Chapman, Watts, Macaffer B, Neade J EMR: Karnezis, Lee T

Bartel or Chapman? Any other comments?
What sort of avg score you reckon i would get with this lineup?

[Griffo1982]

Go Bartel over Chapman, i can see Chappy missing games through player management this year.
Remember to swap Neade with Karnezis, Watts is an interesting one but could prove a nice POD otherwise looking much better.

[Scrays]

Cheers mate. Appreciate the feedback. no doubt will tinker a little futher