Long time reader, give us ya thoughts...

Started by Dooga, March 20, 2013, 02:19:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Dooga

Been a long time reader and just after some thoughts please

Def - Goddard, Gibbs, hartlett, goodes, pittard, terlich (Stevenson, frost)
Mids - gaj, pendlebury, danger, fyfe, hannebery, Lucas, wines, o'meara (Mitchell, viney)
Rucks - cox, smith (currie, moller aka not so floating donut but ill change him)
For - franklin, bartel, rockliff, Martin, karnezis, macaffer (Rowe, neade)

Cash left 218,000

Now I want to use that money, and I've got a couple options...

Option 1 - downgrade Kane Mitchell to Dane rampe and then go neade to gus monfries (this depends on whether macaffer is named round 1 really)

Option 2 - downgrade Mitchell again, go fyfe up to deledio (pod and doesn't have fyfes shoulder), and one of the rook backs to tiny Armstrong

Option 3 - downgrade fyfe to rookie mid and then get watts in back or forward or heppell or anyone of that price

Option 4 - straight upgrade z smith to anyone below sandilands

Option 5 - stand pat and bank the cash

Anyone?

Sabretooth Tigers

 :)
Good side Dooga, reckon you'll do well with it. Of the options you gave, I like the Monfries in to the forward line the best. Would like it even more if it was B Crouch going in as the rookie. Best of luck mate. ;)

Danstar

Even though Zac Smith might do well. Still a young ruckman and at his price and the money you have spare, I would go with someone more reliable

Dooga

Thanks boys, I like monfries new role with port and yeah that was actually another option I forgot to put down...rucks are just such a headache I can't honestly pick one and be confident with him and I feel z smith could really do well, doesn't have much competition for ruck time really and with primus showing him the ropes could soar but key word there is could....

Dooga


tor01doc

Def - excellent - if Frost doesn't get selected consider Luke Brown

Mids - I wonder if you're being a bit cheap by selecting both Fyfe and Hannebery - will either outscore the guys in this list - Swan, Beams, Watson, JPK, Cotchin, Selwood, Lids and a few more I can't think of?
If you don't think so, then you are wasting trades or selling your final team short.
Rucks - Cox is a forward this year. For sure. Leue if selected. Smith OK.

Fwd - Cox in for Martin. Consider Zorko - he looks on fire. Rowe to R4.

A few mid pricers to consider - Moloney, Lucas, Simpkin if selected, B Hill, J Russell, Yarran, Embley, JJK, Varcoe, Bailey if you've got balls, some like K Harper, Petterd?

Good luck.

Dooga

All fair calls...instead of trying to get Monfries in the forward or Armstrong in back with fyfe, reckon I should just upgrade fyfe to a super premium?

tor01doc

My new strategy involves only getting premiums you want in your final best team - ie those top 6/8/2/6 in their lines.

Fyfe top 8?? Maybe but his shoulder might disagree.

Any player other than top ranked is purely a cash cow IMO.

Predicting them can be fun but notoriously difficult.

30 trades will only be enough if you pretend you've got 20.

We had a bin that was only just a tiny bit too small, so some weeks we had to snaeak some rubbish under the cloak of darkness into our old neighbour's bin.  :-[

Then we got a big motherflowering bin, and you know what? We still fill it!


Watch those trades!

Dooga

Haha makes a lot of sense, probably best to upgrade fyfe then cause I can't bring myself to part with hannebery...