First year on SC please rate my team

[Sargikay]

Uploaded with ImageShack.us

[Sargikay]

Some one please give me feedback?

[sammy123]

goddard needs to be in your defence. And you need to xhange dwyer he didnt get off rookue list

[bensl]

to much $$ in your mids.  move goddard back and bring in a rookie (wines, mitchell etc)

[Ramus]

Sandilands is injured (I think!).
Midfield is too heavy, move Goddard back to defence.
Don't think much of Varcoe at present!
Personally, I'm not a fan of tall forwards, they are too hit and miss, I like Mid/Fwds or Ruck/Fwds, just my preference though!

[HotTiges]

hmm, good team for your 1st try but if you want to mix it with us guys you will prob have to do is to get your structures right :

BACKS - 3 premos at least.. too risky with Armstrong D3

MIDS - Prob too heavy? only need 4 - 5 premos.. don't think Goddard should be there. Switch with Vlaustin/

RUCKS - Sandi out for a month or something? Got Sauce myself. Get Cox in the ruck and Rowe becomes relevant or swap Cox fwds/Rowe ruck bench for Currie..

FWDS - Tail of woe.. It's like batting Phil Tufnell at number 8!! Varcoe? fair enough not too bad bit risky as he has never set SC on fire.  Kerridge and Rowe as your last Fwds are a worry. Rowe is almost useless unless you have Cox in the ruck or vice versa. As stated, Dwyer is out too. Kerridge may be 50/50 or sub fodder again..

keep working and don't be afraid to ask..

[the captain]

Def: Get rid of Armstrong, move Goddard into here. Probably also need a mid price at least in there, if not another premium, maybe vlaustin to someone. 6/10
Mid: Goddard for Wines. Very strong otherwise, maybe to strong. 8/10
Ruc: Sandy to Cox and you're good. 8/10
Fwd: Good, go Dwyer to Neade and watch to see if Rowe plays. 7/10

Overall 7/10

[Sargikay]

thanks for all the help guys