SECOND GO..CAN I GET FEEDBACK PLEASE

Started by swandog, March 18, 2013, 10:11:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

swandog

D- Goddard Gibbs Duffield Watts Goodes Stevenson (Terlich Colquhoun)

M- Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Cotchin Moloney Lucas K.Mitchell O'Meara (Crouch Viney)

R- Goldstein Vardy (Blicavs Currie)

F- Franklin Cox Rockliff LeCras Karnezis Byrnes (Macaffer Neade)

$1,000 left

HotTiges

DEF - looks good. nice and strong.
MIDS - likewise. hope Lucas kicks on.. he's due
RUCKS - interesting. all 4 should play sometime during the year. Watch Vardy though, not sure if he's fully fit yet. You could almost go a bit riskier with starting Blicvas and get Rowe in to DPP with Cox otherwise no good. Least Currie will come in if Goldy isn't selected.
FWDS - Pretty good. Franklin a little underdone pre-season? should be right though. rather J Kennedy over LeCras. Byrnes? not sure he is a good SuperCoach pick, however with not much rookie FWDS he maybe ok

8/10 just a bit of tinkering to make it real solid..

the captain

Def: Good, nothing really wrong here.
Mid: Personally not a fan of Moloney, but he did look good on Friday night. Hopefully Lucas improves this year, looking like he should based on nab cup form.
Ruc: Very very risky playing Vardy, really need to upgrade him to berger, both unlikely to play round 1, but berger should do better, if you can find the cash.
Fwd: Good, really don't like Byrnes, but not many good forward rookies, maybe downgrade to Lee then use the money to upgrade Vardy.

swandog

Quote from: HotTiges on March 18, 2013, 10:30:18 PM
DEF - looks good. nice and strong.
MIDS - likewise. hope Lucas kicks on.. he's due
RUCKS - interesting. all 4 should play sometime during the year. Watch Vardy though, not sure if he's fully fit yet. You could almost go a bit riskier with starting Blicvas and get Rowe in to DPP with Cox otherwise no good. Least Currie will come in if Goldy isn't selected.
FWDS - Pretty good. Franklin a little underdone pre-season? should be right though. rather J Kennedy over LeCras. Byrnes? not sure he is a good SuperCoach pick, however with not much rookie FWDS he maybe ok

8/10 just a bit of tinkering to make it real solid..
Thanks for the feedback mate.
Taking a punt with Lucas. I think Buddy should be ok. The way I see it. To buy him ill have to sacrifice to trades for him. Rucks are annoying me immensely so I've gone outside the box here. Blicavs is now a forward/ruck and scored big in his praccy games. While Vardy was high 100's on Friday. If there is an injury then big Cox can fill the void. Goldy is a risk but I think I gotta do it. Played ok over the weekend too.
Agree with Byrnes. I don't want him but who else is there thats going to give u game time. That's all I'm after from him. His break even will be low. LeCras no good? Really? You'd rather Kennedy? Why's that?

HotTiges

Cool. Yeah with the LeCras vs Kennedy i just feel Kennedy, with Q gone and NicNat missing early Kennedy will shine. LeCras is very good player but had been touted as a 'potential midfield rotation' a couple of years ago and that didn't venture.. coming back from injury I reckon he'll slide into the FWD pocket where he does his best work..and the fact Kennedy is cheaper is handy also. I might be wrong about LeCras and I would of jumped on if he was cheap as Kennedy.. your choice though..