Is this the team to beat??

Started by j, March 17, 2013, 05:36:57 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

j

Backs- Goddard, Hartlett, Golby, Goodes, Docherty, Terlich (Stevenson, Van unen)
Mids- Pendlebury, JPK, Dangerfield, Cotchin, Murphy, Jack, Molony, Wines (Viney, O'Meara)
Rucks- Leuy, Vardy (Witts, Currie)
Forwards- Cox, Rockliff, Martin, Jetta, Byrnes, Macaffer, (Stringer, Lee)
$12200 left over.
What do you guys think?

j

Any advice would be appreciated especially with my rucks

teomanbro

def: looks decent, try and fit gibbs in there somehow! maybe go for pittard for van unen?

mid: maybe a bit to strong? id downgrade, murphy and moloney for crouch and mitchell, then you will have plenty left over to get gibbs.

forward: cant fualt the forward line, jetta might be a great POD! sydney have a easy start to the season! stringer is injured, get some1 like neade.

gl!

j

#3
Made a few changes I think this is it!

Backs- Goddard, Hartlett, Golby, Goodes, Docherty, Terlich (Stevenson, Van unen)
Mids- Pendlebury, JPK, Dangerfield, Cotchin, Murphy, Jack, monfries, Wines (Viney, O'Meara)
Rucks- Jenkins, Gorringe (Witts, Currie)
Forwards- Cox, Rockliff, Martin, Jetta, Byrnes, Stringer, (Neade, Lee)
$57700 left over

j


FisherSaints

Definetly one of the stronger teams I've seen. I don't particularly like Monfries, could go for someone else like Crouch and then upgrade Golby. Change Witts to Rowe to get DPP with Cox

9/10

Can you rate my team here

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74319.msg1023584.html#msg1023584

Knowall

I question whether you can reliably get at least one of stringer, neade or Lee playing.  Ideally you would want 2 or 3 of them playing so you have an emergency.  But i guess you can swap Monfries and Neade over if need be.

Any reason why you havent go Maccaffer.

I think Van Unen has played very little in the pre-season, dont like his chances of playing early

What sort of scores are you expecting from Jenkins?
also how confident are you that youll be able to fill your Ruck 2 with gorringe, witts, currie?

Give my team a rating http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74310.0.html


j

I liked the look of stringer and there's a spot in the dogs forward line for him word is he'll be right for round one, his injury was only minor. Rookies will prob change when I see the final team line ups and I am considering Macaffer. Adelaide are trying Jenkins in tippets old role so I think he will get decent numbers, Gorringe I'm not sure he was just the best I could afford. And he should get games given he's the saints number 2 ruck, I hope

j


ubeaut

I love strong mids it's what I'm aiming for too, but that's a bit too strong IMO. U need another mid rookie or 2 to make good cash. Really dunno about Golby - u need Gibbs.

I would go GAJ,Pendles,JPK,Danger,Murphy and Moloney. 5 prems plus Moloney. IF U WANT A STRONG MIDFIELD SURELY U NEED THE BEST PLAYER IN SUPERCOACH?(Ablett)Then spend any left over money on rucks and fwds.

j

I think GAj is a little over priced to start with as is franklin so they will be my upgrade targets come round7, at least that's the plan. I swapped monfries to L Parker for now. I would like Gibbs but the only way I could afford him now is to trade in Hartlett which I'm not all that keen on.

j

There's a lot of people looking but not a lot rating

pieman18

i am sorry mate but you only have 9 prems and most have 13-14...i cant see this side finishing above 150,000.....sorry...harsh but i think accurate....to read it , i would expect you still had 500,000 to use...