Final Team 'Please Rate'

Started by greco272, March 17, 2013, 12:02:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

greco272

Goddard, Gibbs, Duffield, Broughton, Goodes, Douchtey (Stevenson, Terlich)

Ablett, Pendels, Cotchin, Murphy, Moloney, K.Stevens, O.Wines, O.Mera (Viney, Crouch)

Cox, Goldstein (Rowe, Currie)

Franklin, Rockliff, Martin, Varcoe, Karnezis, Mcaffa (T.Lee, Neade)

31k left

Is moloney at M5 to weak? Is Varcoe at F4 too weak? Any thoughts were i could change it up?

(will rate back just post a link to your team)

j

Your backs and rucks are too strong (that's not where you get your points) making your mids and forwards weaker,  could make some suggestions, not sure if you want to hear all of them though.

greco272

Wouldn't mind hearing them if you have time?

Knowall

Just looking at your team and your Fwd line is too weak, i think.  Id strongly consider ditching one of Broughton, Duffield and MOloney and upgrading your forwards.  Probably one of Varcoe or Karnezis, dont think youll have enough money to upgrade Lee to anything worthwhile.  Walker, Zorko, Bartel?
Secondly id look at ditching Goldstein.  Currie is putting pressure on his position and if your paying just under 497k for somebody you want their position to be secure.  Consider Mumford, Kreuzer, Bellchambers instead.  If you have more money consider Jacobs or ROughead.

please rate my team in my latest reply
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74310.0.html

j

Ok we'll I doubt everyone will agree with all of this but here it goes.
Broughton-> Atley
Duffield-> Golby
Cox-> Jacobs
Goldy-> Z Smith
Franklin->  Cox
Karnezis-> Byrnes
Varcoe-> Lewis Jetta
Molony-> Fyfe
And you should have about $15k left if I got the numbers right.
I think franklin should be an upgrade target around round 7.

johnnytheboy1

Backs Solid with good backs only problem is you may have spent too much here
Mids: Would look at leaving Stevens out although he only played the first half didn't do much though only 5 possessions would have recommended Lonergan but he got injured yesterday
Rucks: Very Solid
Fwds: Replace Varcoe with Kennedy

Overall Team has good balance 8/10