Please rate my SC team (try again).

[teachrtony]

ok, so can't do the image thing!

Backs- Goddard;Birchall;Hanley;Vlastuin;Goodes;L.Stevenson (R.Laird;Terlich)
Mids- Swan;Danger;S.Mitchell;Gibbs;Boak;Moloney;Embley;Wines (Crouch;O'Meara)
Rucks-Cox;Longer (Gorringe;Currie)
Forwards- Roughead;Zorko;D.Martin;LeCras;J.Kennedy;Varcoe (McCaffer;Lee)

[pooj11]

how to display your pic: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,46783.0.html

Def: need Gibbs in there, instead of the mid. Swap him with goodes. 7.5/10
Mid: Not bad, deffs need Ablett in there. Embley/Moloney ----> a rookie (K.mitchell) and with the cash, S.Mitchell ----> Ablett. better options than Boak IMO. 8/10
Ruck: better options than Longer IMO. 9/10
For: missing the big premium, downgrade LeCras/Kennedy/Varcoe to a rookie (Neade) then with the cash, Roughead ---> Franklin. 8/10

Overall: not a bad team, just need to work on it a little, 32.5/40

good luck :)

please rate my team: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74382.0.html

[teachrtony]

Cheers Pooj11. I have had all of the variations you suggest over the past couple of weeks. I really think that there won't be many rookies getting games though. The past two years we have had GWS and the Suns which I think have spoiled us. Port have a great first 4 rounds (apart from Crows Rd3) so am thinking Boak will lift in value considerably, with the hope that Gablett drops. Embley/Moloney should lift alot too, so the plan is to upgrade early with Beames/Ablett/Pendles etc.

Is still a work in progress though (until gametime this friday lol) so thanks for the input.

[DC13]

DEF: First of all, id probably swap birchall to gibbs if you can, gibbs has a much higher scoring potential in the mids this year, I think birchall will stay around 94. The rest is good and really think Hanley will do great this year, dominated in the NAB cup final apart from a couple of early errors but improved from that later in the game. Not sure who Laird is but the rest of the rookies are good, hopefully Vlastuin is in best 22 and isn't subbed. 7/10

MID: Very very different and unique midfield. No Ablett is a big risk however the 3 super prems you have are very good, S. Mitchell is a good POD. if you really think the DPP to defence is important then feel free to keep gibbs there but I think its a bit of a risk and he is better at D2, with the 18 players through the byes I think youll get away with it and you need a stronger midfielder at M4. Like the Boak choice, played well today from what ive heard and could be a real improver. Moloney is a basic pick, should rack up points being the main clearance player at the lions. Wouldn't go with embley myself, too injury prone lately and is getting old, id save cash and get a rookie, lots of talent. 8/10

RUCK: Cox is a good choice with the forward link to roughy, however I don't think longer is a great pick at R2, looked very rusty last night in my opinion, gorringe I was considering and got to go with currie. try finding an alternative to longer. 6/10

FWD: Very good. Missing buddy and rocky but they are in a lot of teams so alternatives are good. Not sure on lecras due to consistency but could pay off, like the kennedy pick and varcoe which guarantees all your forwards will be playing. 9/10

Overall: A few things to fix up. recommend changing longer in ruck to someone more proven and downgrade embley to rookie as well as putting gibbs back in defence to get a better mid. if you want to keep DPP then id use Vlastuin in mids. Best of luck mate :) 30/40

Please rate mine: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74383.0.html

[HotTiges]

should get rid of Embley, he's past it now.. rookie up