Final team- thoughts- Ill rate your team if you rate mine

[bkp130]

Final Team..............I think

Money Left: $34 300

Backs- Gibbs, Duffield, Hibberd, Vlastuin,  Goodes, Docherty (Stevensen, Terlich)

Midfield- Ablett (C), Pendlebury,  JP Kennedy, Dangerfield, Shuey, Lower, Moloney, Stevens (O'mera/Viney)

Rucks- S. Martin, J Jenkins (D Currie/ McBean)

Fowards--Franklin, Cox, Rockliff, Karnezis, Byrnes, Macaffer (Neade/Lee)


Only Thoughts i have had so far are possibly downgrading franklin or shuey and upgrading a ruck or adding another midpriced defender. Also not sure on neade and lee as rookie fowards. any other suggestions

Let me know what you think.

[tbagrocks]

Just too many mid pricers, especially in the middle, that's where you want at least 4 gun rooks to make cash, otherwise unless all the mid pricers smash it you won't have the cash for upgrades

Need to have O'Meara, Viney, Crouch, Wines even Lonergan possably K Mitchell locked into your midfield

Don't have a problem with any of the players it's just too a risky strategy inm :)

[Regs81]

Good team.. Here are some points,

Def: not sure about hibberd, only played 13 games last year
, although he could be a good POD player , but I would probably upgrade
Mids: looks ok- I would get rid of either moloney/lower and replace with
A rookie. That will give u extra cash for your defense or ruck
Ruck: needs work. Don't think mcbean will get much game time, maybe
Replace with Rowe. Upgrade either Martin/Jenkins. Both are mid
priced and I think you need one premium.
Forward: really like
Good team mate 8/10

[spasticnut]

Not a bad team but only counting 10 premo's here. I give it a 6.5/10 atm. Hibberd too big of a risk at d3. Love the midfield but unfortunately rucks, forward and defence too weak. Need a super premo in the ruck, defence and forward line. Too many mid pricers but can compete. Sorry for the harsh rating but i hope u are as honest with my team :) http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74201.0.html

[bkp130]

Hey mate nope i was after honest criticism so i appreciate it. In regars to rucks i think they will both average about 70 which i happy to take. And hibberd at D3 as above im happy with as last year before he hurt himself he was playing really well so im using him as a POD

[Goolahbah]

Hibberd not so sure about, much better options out there.

Rucks too light....

fwds little light too

All because not enough rookie mids... think about viney, mitchell, wines, o meara, brad crouch, toumpas, etc

Mine: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74215.0.html

[prozz710]

Agree a lot with what has been said above;
I think it is better to go premos and rookies in the midfield, maybe one middy, but two is probably one to many. Also the ruck situation i would try and get one gun in as rucks get points so easily nowadays its too risky to pass up those scores