Blues all the way! Please rate my team only my first time doing SC though!

Started by Carltonblues5, March 14, 2013, 08:12:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Carltonblues5

BACKS:   Goddard,B  Gibbs,B  Birchall,G  Vlastuin,N  Docherty,S   Colquhoun,           (S Stevenson,L Frost, J)

MIDFIELD:    Ablett,G  Watson,J  Cotchin,T  Mcveigh,J. Moloney,B  Ball, L  Whitfield,L   Mitchell,K      (Viney,J  O'Meara, J)

RUCKMEN:  Jacobs,S  Kreuzer,M       (Daw,M Currie,D)

FORWARDS:    Franklin,L  Johnson,S  Martin,D  Jetta,L (syd) Kennedy,J  Varcoe,T          (Neade,J.   Dwyer,S)

Thanks dont mind any criticism and suggestions

FactHunt

Hey mate, not too bad.

Backs look pretty good, not too sure on job security for colqhorn though.. other options could be goodes, pittard or brown. Can wait and see how they go this weekend.

Mids ok.. mcveigh is definitely a POD. Ball looks like missing early still.. would recommend ball to rookie and upgrade mcveigh to a elite premium. If ya set on mcveigh id still go ball to rook and look for him when he comes back. Use the cash to upgrade elsewhere to get more points early.

Rucks are solid.

Forwards look good too, unfortunately SJ to miss early with suspension.. maybe look to get him in later if you really like him.


Carltonblues5

I Actually don't have Stevie j I forgot to change him he's actually kent to be Tom rockliff

KTDL

Quote from: Carltonblues5 on March 14, 2013, 08:12:56 PM
BACKS:   Goddard,B  Gibbs,B  Birchall,G  Vlastuin,N  Docherty,S   Colquhoun,           (S Stevenson,L Frost, J)

MIDFIELD:    Ablett,G  Watson,J  Cotchin,T  Mcveigh,J. Moloney,B  Ball, L  Whitfield,L   Mitchell,K      (Viney,J  O'Meara, J)

RUCKMEN:  Jacobs,S  Kreuzer,M       (Daw,M Currie,D)

FORWARDS:    Franklin,L  Johnson,S  Martin,D  Jetta,L (syd) Kennedy,J  Varcoe,T          (Neade,J.   Dwyer,S)

Thanks dont mind any criticism and suggestions

Backs- like it. Vlastuin is a star rookie but I think sub time will be coming to him quite often. Don't know frost. Where's Terlich? He's a lock mate.
Mids- 3 jets are stock, could go another I think. Pending cash u have left. McVeigh? Not sold. Moloney I like. Ball is a long way off bud. Avid Pie supporter. He's a while off. Word is Whitfield will be eased into it seeing they have already got loads of young mids. At that price I'd avoid and go wines. He's a starter I reckon. Other 3 I like.
Rucks- Jacobs yes, kreuz????..dunno.currie yes or daw. Maybe go Witts before one of those bench players. He will play.
Forwards buddy yes, Johnno susp week 1. I will look at upgrading to him throughout year.martin is interesting..like it. Debated having him in my ruck spot. Good logic here. I think the rest are a little weak mate. Sorry. Neade I hope plays. Varcoe I don't trust with injuries. Jetta I think u can do better.kennedy interesting...seen a few sides with him. Could be worth it. Dwyer I have doubts. Won't make u much cash.
How much cash u got left over cos there's room for improvement I think. I'm clearly no expert, just my thoughts.