is this to risky?

Started by dejan, March 14, 2013, 04:07:22 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Is this to risky?

Yes
12 (57.1%)
No
9 (42.9%)
Other Please post
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 0

dejan

Hey guys i want to start with Currie as my R2 is this to risky and i have rowe as back up.
i have jacobs in as r1 and cox upfront.

Rowan1812

Goldstein is the number 1 ruck at north melbourne and they wont play both so dont put him ruck 2 as he prob wont play much unless goldstein gets injured or doesnt perform

Toga

I think it is too risky!

Goldy is still #1, Currie might not even feature in round 1 for all we know, I highly doubt they will drop Goldy- even if he does play, half of his DT score on the weekend came from hit outs (while he was sole ruckman) playing alongside Goldy he won't get anywhere near as many points from HO... So will rely on getting more possessions, which I'm not confident he can get.

I would much rather Billy Longer than Currie if you can afford him, but there's still risk involved with that. I'm looking at just going set and forget with Cox & Maric/Roughead tbh!

Windigo

Goldy & H-Mac never worked, so Goldy & Currie wouldn't work also presumably... :-\

Not keen on forking out near 1 million for rucks TBH. 


timmyparso

Quote from: Toga on March 14, 2013, 04:43:14 PM
I think it is too risky!

Goldy is still #1, Currie might not even feature in round 1 for all we know, I highly doubt they will drop Goldy- even if he does play, half of his DT score on the weekend came from hit outs (while he was sole ruckman) playing alongside Goldy he won't get anywhere near as many points from HO... So will rely on getting more possessions, which I'm not confident he can get.

I would much rather Billy Longer than Currie if you can afford him, but there's still risk involved with that. I'm looking at just going set and forget with Cox & Maric/Roughead tbh!

agree here.

Zac Smith is scoring at 85 points per 100mins played in NAB to date so is another good replacement for Leuy at R2. Don't judge his last game score too harshly either as he had minimal time on ground. The cox/rowe link can be used if Smith (or Longer or other) don't perform early.

Toga

Quote from: Windigo on March 14, 2013, 04:59:06 PM
Goldy & H-Mac never worked, so Goldy & Currie wouldn't work also presumably... :-\

Not keen on forking out near 1 million for rucks TBH.

what's your strategy gonna be then Windi? :-\