Premium mids!

Started by lukebomber, March 12, 2013, 09:14:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which pair for M4/M5?

J.Selwood/D.Hannerbery
M.Priddis/D.Mundy

lukebomber

Torn between theses two options for my M4/M5 picks, I think hannerberry is in for a break out year and could be a good unique but mundy could be the safer option??

jfitty

My vote went to Priddis & Mundy.

So much to like about Mundy this year. Great preseason, and is in line to get back to his 2011 form before he got injured. Priddis is an interesting one. Always flies under the radar, and if you take out his injury affected game last season he averaged just under 115, which puts him in the Boyd/Murphy/Cotchin spectrum. Not saying that he is as good as these guys, but his consistency (only 3 scores under 100 last year besides the injury game) makes him a fantastic unique pick.

Colliwobblers

JSelwood is a great SC scorer had a down season last year, expect a fair bit better from him this season. Only a baby still and needs a lot of those around him to step up.

Hann is a risk being new to the premium ranks but i expect him to keep improving too and with such a cakewalk for an early draw the risk in starting him in minimal.

option 1 for me, too many guns at west coast priddis is going to have shuey and gaff go past him in a hurry i reckon.

mundy meh, didn't really excite me last season but another preseason under Lyons a lot of those purple lads may improve this season, still not for me.

quinny88

Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 12, 2013, 09:56:34 PM
JSelwood is a great SC scorer had a down season last year, expect a fair bit better from him this season. Only a baby still and needs a lot of those around him to step up.

Hann is a risk being new to the premium ranks but i expect him to keep improving too and with such a cakewalk for an early draw the risk in starting him in minimal.

option 1 for me, too many guns at west coast priddis is going to have shuey and gaff go past him in a hurry i reckon.

mundy meh, didn't really excite me last season but another preseason under Lyons a lot of those purple lads may improve this season, still not for me.

A down year for Selwood? he averaged 0.2 less than his best season in 2010

colmullet

i dunno if i'd take selwood this year....not just for the concussion he invariably gets...but also the ruck stocks at Geelong are bottom of the barrel at the moment, he's not going to be getting served on a plate at all compared to guys from other clubs. He will score well i just don't think he will improve is all

lukebomber

With spare cash instead of Selwood i could afford Danger or cotchin, is that a better option?

Colliwobblers

Quote from: quinny88 on March 12, 2013, 10:09:39 PM
Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 12, 2013, 09:56:34 PM
JSelwood is a great SC scorer had a down season last year, expect a fair bit better from him this season. Only a baby still and needs a lot of those around him to step up.

Hann is a risk being new to the premium ranks but i expect him to keep improving too and with such a cakewalk for an early draw the risk in starting him in minimal.

option 1 for me, too many guns at west coast priddis is going to have shuey and gaff go past him in a hurry i reckon.

mundy meh, didn't really excite me last season but another preseason under Lyons a lot of those purple lads may improve this season, still not for me.

A down year for Selwood? he averaged 0.2 less than his best season in 2010

Yes and he was 23 years old in his first season as captain in a side on the down ( if only slightly).

He should continue to improve. he didn't last season

that said i would consider danger or cotchin over him all 3 kick goals win contested possessions and influence games - SC Gold.

tbagrocks

Neither!

Maybe Priddis but he won't be a top 10, will score nicely but not top 10

Honestly if you want to gamble on a 110 breakout it's Fyfe or Sloane

tor01doc

Danger.

And maybe Fyfe.

The sky's the limit with these 2.

charliesheen

priddis/mundy out of those choices