Ask Torp!

[Torpedo10]

Torp, what are your thoughts on Heath Shaw? Had him locked in the back line since 2013 opened. Also got Goddard, Heppel, duffield and Gibbs in the midfield for dpp.

Thanks Mick

I've never liked Heath Shaw and always seems to have some off matches but he has a really good average and can't really argue with that. I would downgrade him to a rookie just because of the other defenders you have already. What does the rest of your team look like?

B: Goddard, shaw, hepp, duffield,Vlaastuin, goodes, Pittard, docherty
M: swan, jpk, danger, Gibbs, Mundy, koby, Jaeger, viney, crouch,Kommer
R: roughy, Berger, Rowe, currie
F: buddy, Cox, rockliff, varcoe,Karnezis,Byrnes, lee, macaffer

Still iffy on fwd line and ruck. Really looking for Heath to be a top defender this year, but he can be up and down like u say. Not sure I can afford to make him a rookie tho, really need another prem defender. Maybe Gibs down back and lose dpp or bring goodes up? Then another mid?

DEF: All looks pretty good although I would upgrade Duff>Gibbs if you can.
MID: Swapp Gibbs with Goodes down back, Swap Goodes with another decent Midfielder rookie and downgrade Duffman to Goodes down back. I would try and sideswap Kommer, he won't get a regular game at the bombers. Try and find the cash to upgrade Swanny to GAJ.
RUCKS: See if you can upgrade Leuy to a premo ruck other than that very good rucks with Roughy.
FWDS: Downgrade Buddy to Martin and use the cash to upgrade Leuy.