any htoughts/ratings

[TheBombres]

B:  Goddard - drummond - hodge - gilbee   
     ellis - malceski - hunt     (maguire - trengrove)

M:   Murphy - selwood - watson - cooney
      cotchin - trengrove       (martin - jetta)

R:    Tippett - warnock          (roughhead - lobbe)

F:     Riewoldt - o'keefe - didak - franklin
        dangerfield - rohan -rockliff  (gumbleton - hitchcock)

A bit short in a few areas i realise but any suggestions and/or ratings would be greatly appreciated

[bjrouse]

Backs aren't that bad assuming Ellis and Malceski step up to the plate.

Mids pretty good although Murphy is out rd1. I want to see a full season from Cotchin before getting on.

Rucks. No to Warnock. He got dominated on the weekend. Bench at best

Forwards. If Didak gets a heavy tag like he did on the weekend he wont score well and his scores will look like a mountain range.
Rohan and Rockliff might hurt with both being in your starting 22.

[TheBombres]

I realise warnock may struggle but can't see value in 2 expensive rucks which is the lowest scoring of the lines.

Thinking mitchell in for murphy now too and upgrading rohan to someone in the 250+'s  if possible

[bjrouse]

I realise warnock may struggle but can't see value in 2 expensive rucks which is the lowest scoring of the lines.

All the more reason to get the rucks right...and leave them for the year barring injuries